The Archive · 1927

SATIONAL DEVELOPMENT IN THE PROVISIONAL COURT CASE

Petition by Chief Judge Loo for Investigation of the Charge! of Laxness Brought by Nanking Official The Shanghai Provisional Court sensation took a new turn last Frida when Chief Judge Loo Hsing-yuan filed a petition to the Nationalist Government at Nanking asking for 'a public indictment of the Kiangsu Provincial Commissioner of Justice who is alleged to have made a false ecusation against Mr. Loo leading to his consequent unlawful di missal, We publish below a summary of the document which will rebably go down to history as the first document of its kind recording the challenge of a judge against the Executive Government in his fight for Independence of the of judiciary in this country.

1, On October 20, 1927, the petitioner received an oficial order {from the Kiangsu Provincial Commissioner of Justice to the effect that the said Commissioner having moved to. the Provincial Govern -ment that the President of the Shang hai Provincial Court be dismissed on account of his Inxness in hand-

Ling affairs, it is hereby notified that! the motion was caryled and he in requested to obey the onder.

2. That while it ought to be his uty to obey the order, the petitionee constrained to submit that the order is legally defective since it la. contrary to the Constitutional Pact of the Republic of China which is still the fundamental Inv!

the land and. the birthright of Thinese people, as well as the Lay governing the Discipline of Judicial naturally look for the protection their life and property, that since its rendition, the experiment of this Court is being watched by the whole world and will be the acid test of the desirability of doing away with consular jurisdiction which the foreigners enjoy, and the success or failure of this Court will depend upon the ability of its judges to mete out justice and to observe law impartially, the petitioner has deemed it his sacred trast to uph the Court's honour and prestige and has, in a small measure, succeeded in this regard.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account