Mr. W. 8. Fleming appeared for the plaintiffs, Dr. F. E. Hinckley 1 the defendants. requesting the Court to enter an order of reference to " master for examina-
-|tion of accounts submitted aad offered by the defendsots. The reason for motion was that the conceding the equity of the bill for scconnting yet, taking the prayer for an scconnting, had endeavoured to meet the substance of that prayer by submitting and offering to the Court certain accounts which bad been sworn to, The object of this motion was to suggest that these accounts, being io detail, might be more than the itself would care to examine, and the defendants suggested and requested that a master io ¢q ial master, appointed for the examination of these accounts and report on them to the Court. In pursuance of this motion, and should it be granted, the defendants were ready to submit " form of order of reference for the consideration of the Court, although the form of that order the defendants did not undertake to suggest any farther thoo might be requested by the Court. It did not seem necessary to argue the propriety eubmittiog these accounts inasmuch as the prayer of the plaintiffs covered the matter entirely, and it seemed entirely in accord with the prayer of the plaintiffs. However, if the Coart desired to hear farther argoment on the motion in respect especially to its propriety and whether it tended to equity and to bring about an early settlement of this controversy, the defendants were ready to offer it.
Mr. Fleming said that it now appeared that the dofeodante came before the Court at the eleventh hour and offered to) famish the sccoantiog 516 prayed for in the bill of complaint. If this offer amounted to an unqualified consent to the entry of a decree in accordance with the prayer of the bill of complaint, plaintiffs would sooept it. Plaintiffs would agree to the acceptance of a decree in accordance with the prayer of the bill of complainant and in no other form.
His Honour seid that he interpreted this motion on the part of the defendants as consenting to a fall so count, mich was the substance and cadence of the complaint presented by the complainants. The plaintiffs asked that the Court upon statement made, find that an accounting was das; this had been demanded snd bad been filed.
Now the defendant came into Court and conceded an soconnt. In the motion as prepared la a certain paragraph, the Coart noticed that the defendants aid that were "reserving, maintaining and affirming every defence and defences in their answer to the bill for accounting." If the Court construed that to mean the possible assertion of the righto, as sot forth io their answer, the Court woold not order decree.
Bat the Court construed that Iengaage as meaning that without as senting to the legal propreitions as laid down in the complaint as affording the basis of the issuance of the decree necessary, the defendants consented to an accounting which amounted to practically fall complisoce with the complaint in this case. However, the reservation was made in which the defendants chose to say that they did not consider that they were compelled to make the acconntiog as a matter of law or right. Defendants conceded the so count asked for. His Honour did not know if the Court quite understood counsel for the plaintiffs in his aeertion that morning that a decree must necessarily conform in every respect to the bill of complaint, In the course of drafting " bill of complaint, a plaintiff or his counsel might sot forth many things which might or might not on fall showing, appeal to the Count, or might or might not be essential to the relief which was asked for. In the present case the ction taken that morning by the defendants gave to the plaintitts all that they asked for, and it would be futile for the Court to undertake to discuss the details set forth in the complaint and to ascertain whether each one was justified or not as matter of fect or law. That was the way the matter impressed the Coart.
Mr, Fleming stated that he agreed absolutely with his Honour on this, The prayer asked for a fall accounting of the basioess of this concern from January 1, 1908 to December 31, 1910, That was. all the prayer asked for, Plaintiffs asked that the decree, when made, be as fall as that prayer in the petition. The prayer was very brief.
His Honour—I understand that the defendants concede that, I cannot terpret it any other way. If the motion la granted it mnat be a fall scconnting of conten; there can be no reservations. Perliaystie phzase cand) here is unfort-
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.