'THE conditions of dairy licences published in yesterday's Municipal Gazette afford a mel-anchaly example of the sterility which too often befalls the work of Special Commissions. It may be a small matter that whereas the Pure Milk Commission was appointed in April of the year 1928, held fourteen meetings, heard "a mass of evidence, personally inspected nw ber of dairies and sent in 'a voluminous and closely printed report before the end of that year, the new license ing conditions only make their appearance fifteen months later. With the slender and so inadequately remunerated staffs of the Municipal Council, these little delays are no doubt unavoidable. And they might have been overlooked had the licence conditions, when they did appear, been more in accord with the Commission's recommenda-animal certified by the-veterinary surgeon as suffering from any communicable disease and shall forthwith give information as to how the animal has been disposed of to the Commissioner of Public Health, Under Grade B, the' licensee is immediately fo notify the Commissioner of Public Health of the death of any animal and "any animal suffering from dis ease shall be disposed of in a manner satisfactory to the Commissioner." There may be an incinerator somewhere -in the background, but nothing is said about it, The utter inefficacy of the new licensing conditions' in this respect for the controlling of people so adept at deception as Chinese dairymen needs no explanation, Of course the latter will run risks in not reporting disease, or in saying that a dead cow has been buried when it has actually been sold, but no greater risk than they take every day, perhaps even less. For the health inspectors are very busy men, with many of faith, of broken treaty pledges made and not kept, is not at all clear. The Amer Government must be apprised of the fact that China is to day the largest opium-grower. The American consular offices throughout China must have reports on the activities of the opium-growing militarists, on the nexion between opium polities, on the relationship Letween opium and government Yet, in spite of it all, hen G, Porter insists proposal demanding of Chin what China asks Britain is "quite unaceeptabse.
Why?
Of course, Mr. Porter may have a greater knowledge of China and the Chinese than we have. It has, we believe, been suggested that the less one lives here, the less he studies and reads, the fewer Chinese he personally knows, the better he can understand the offal of this country. 'Me. Porter mi have achieved his erudition in just such a way: 4 trip from Shanghai to Peking under the aegis of the Waichiao pus an occasional letter from someone in China, a sensational headline in' a newspaper and authority on China is made, Yet, in the interminable para-doxas which are China, one must have more foundation than that.
On one day, the people of wei and Nantao oppose even the building of a road by the International Settlement; on another day; they threaten a bully-me general with voluntarily' petitioning for Settlement Extension in order that they may have wood government.
On one day, opium as the curse of China on another day, they permit opium-smuggling officials: to reach high office with apparent popular approval. Opium is undoubtedly " harmful drug, but how many of China's officials do not have the lamp and pipe: in their residences for the en- auth tertainment of their friends?
There are facts and fables in this opium situation, which ma; not be known to those who read their China in terms of hatred for the British Empire.
There ix much to be done for the sup- clu pression of this drug, but let it be done everywhere at once. Britain gave up a luc merce for humani on the understanding that China would give up growing the poppy.
Britain kept her word; China became the world's principal producer of opium.
Britain is willing to continue its humani tarian efforts in the connexion. Why is China unwilling? ernment Suffrage Bill, striking on! the claw which deprived peers of the right to vote or to stand for: the Lower HouserReuter's Pacific of furthermore that if the Chinese]
people wish to have a particular] an group of men sitting as a government, it is for them to provide those men with the means to do their work, For the foreigner to put down the money, when the Chinese people button up their pockets, ix an act of intervention' internal affairs, the end of which is almost certainly: failure and probably disaster. But, on the other hand. if the ticians and military men re-resented in Peking: can show riy semblance of united government, it is not easy for the Powers to reply "Your Government is only a sham and we! don't believe you." And if the! Chinese in power then say, "You promised at Washington to hold'
special conference about our tariffs under certain conditions; we have fulfilled some of them and are ready to fulfil the rest,' there may be no logical reason for refusing.
What, then, are the conditions of the Special Conference? Referring to the Washington Treaty'
find that the first article dealing with the Customs tariff and its annex provide for the raising of dues to an effective! five per cent. and this has already been done. The second article opens as follow:
"Immediate steps shall be taken, through a Special Conference, to prepare the way forthe speedy abolition of likin and for the fulflof the other conditions in Article VIII of the Treat of the 5th September, 1902, between nand China' (certain then named) with a view to levying the surtaxes provided for in those Articles." the third article comes jon that the Conference sions to be applied prior to the abolition of likin and the fulfilment of the other conditions laid down fu the articles of the treaties mentioned in Article IT; and it shall the levying of a surtax on dutiable imports as from such date, for such purposes and subject to such conditions as it may deter-
The order and wording of these resolutions need to be very carefully noted, as the to be the condition of revising' the tariff: in other words. if import duties are to be increased, internal trade must be freed from the intolerable burdens which it has now to endure. This, the true meaning of the resolutions, has lately been reiterated and emphasized by Sir John. Jordan and when the Special Conference meets we may be sure that no other interpretation will be admitted.
Now the special insertion of Tokyo, Mar. 1—The Suftrage the word likin in the Washington Commitice have amended the Gov- Treaty was principally due to the stress laid upon it in the Mackay Treaty. In 1902. likin was the principal bugbear. "In the intervening and particularly in recent One might imagine it to consist of fan. office and a preventive staff collecting duties on the trade that passes its doors. In fact, in addition to such office, there is a cordon of fourteen barriers or sub-stations completely. surrounding the city of Wuhu and no goods can get without being examined and untos accompanied by a transit pass, taxed. In addition to these fourteen Darriers there ate within a fifty Li radius of Wuhu a number of other sub-stations controlled by the foreign Commissioner and beyond the jus still other sub-stations intendent. together constitute the Wal tive Customs, and the object of] establishing so wide a network of: them is to catch the whole trade of South Anhui, 'The writer thinks it extremely' probable that abolition of likin tions. But the latter would appear to have been almost deliberately ignored. And this notwithstanding that the Commission included two men intimately experienced in dairy matters, two doctors of eminent, standing and that its report included a great deal of evidence by a veterinary surgeon.
One point on which the Commission dwelt very strongly was the urgency of engaging a Municipal veterinary surgeon. They said emphatically that "health inspectors are not qualified to diagnose the diseases of cattle. Hence they cannot effectively prevent the spread of disease." The Commission also dealt with "other matters which only an absolute: ly independent and fully qualifiother duties besides nosing about cow stables, even if they had the necessary qualifications to diagnose what might be found there, The dividing of the licences into "A" and "B" Grades accordance with the Commission's recommendations. The idea is that the "B" Grade dairies will, if they fulfil the licence conditions—a rather big assumption in respect of Chinese dairies—produce a milk reasonably fit for all human consumption, under usual precautions of boiling. "A" Grade dairies would produce what might. be called milk de twee; and el where it has been found that: the advertisement of the "A" Grade certificate is so valuable would be followed "by a large|ed increase in the number of substations of Native Custom Houses." Who will disagree with him?
These considerations bring us back forcibly to the sound sense of the resolution passed by the British Chambers of Commerce Conference in 1920: that the opportunity of any revision of the Customs tariff should be taken "to press for the reorganization of the whole system of taxation of trade in China.... and that as a preliminary and practical step this direction the Chinese Government be pressed to abolish forthwith the taxation now levied by! the Chinese Maritime Customs on all goods carried from one port to nother in Chi As the writer quoted above say there is only one way of removing "what impedes the free circulation of commodities" (the intention undoubtedly of the Washington, as it was of the Treaty) and "that is to retain only import and export to be levied when goods are imported into or exported out of China, and to abolish root and branch every other species of taxation on commodities whatever."
It is hardly to be expected that the Peking or provincial governments would consent to this for seven and a half or even twelve per cent. But we believe that: most merchants Chinese and foreign would willingly agree to a higher rate, if they were assured of the reform contemplated. How they are to be so assured, brings us back to the question we began with: What does the Government in Peking really' connote? Is it representative of China? If the Powers are not satisfied of this, to agree to any increase in the Customs duties is merely throwing good money' after bad., Alternatively, they can keep control of the revenues yielded by the Customs, as the Washington Treaty clearly enables them to do. until China produces a Government capable and willing to manage her affairs: veterinary surgeon can con-
And they stuck to this view, after giving "full consideration" to the contrary opin-fon of the Health Department. Well, the Council, in the common phrase, "turned down" the recommendation several months ago, and we do not recollect that it even thought it worth bringing to the notice of ratepayers, in order to ascertain whether they would authorize the necessary expense. The result is the appearance in the "A" grade licensing conditions of a clause fiat against the Commission's express. recommendations, follow:
That an examination of the entire herd be made as frequently as the discretion of the Public Health and at least once in every three months by a properly qualified veterinary surgeon approved by the Council—Grade A. Licence. This is what the Pure Milk Commission said on this point:
Certification every three months bby approved local practising veter-mary surgeons would not prove sufficient to check the spread of tuberculosis, rinderpest or other itrfectious diseases.
Incidentally the "B" grade licen-ices extend the period of inspection to six months. But one point that the Commission had strongly in mind is that it is impracticable to limit the granting of inspection- certificates to one firm of veterinary surgeons and this opens the door to inspection by men not having adequate qualifications and the defeating of the Commission's purpose. Again, we find the Commission dwelling on the important questions of the disposal of war eases of animals dead from disease and the movement of animals suffering from disease over municipal roads.
-and ther "strongly urged. the installation of a municipal incinerator" because there is at present no satisfactory. method disposing of diseased car. cases. On this point all we find in-Grade A licences is this:—
That the Ticensee shall immediate-to dairymen that they are particularly anxious to qualify for, it and thereby the whole supply of the city's milk tends to be improved. Whether this will be the case in Shanghai appears to us doubtful, The licensing conditions now published embody most of the Commission's recommendations for ensuring cleanliness of premises, bottles and operators: it is in respect. of the machinery for putting them into and keeping them in effect that the regulations are so weak. That was the defect on which the Commission f ened at once, the essential point on which they pressed for remedy, indicating what that remedy should be. For one fur: ther example: the Commission urged that licences should be attached to premises, not to individuals, which would enable the Council to shut up a repeatedly offending dairy. W may have overlooked in some issue of the Municipal Gazette some paragraph stating that this precaution is henceforward to be adopted. But there is not a trace of it in the Ueensing conditions themselves, the whole suggestion of which indeed is precisely the contrary." In a word, the' new regulation' could quite easily have been drafted by anybody equipped with some elementary knowledge of hygiene, without all the labour and expense involved in the meetings of the Pure Milk Commission. A more cynical burke of the vital parts of the Cor mission's urgent representations it would be difficult to imagine, If the public, departments are to be permitted to defeat the mature. conclusions of special commissions in this ianner, ratepayers will scarcely: be encouraged to give their time to such unfruitful tasks, ment contemplates appointing, Mr.
Peking, Feb, 26-—The Gores Tu An as. Asvociate-Dirseir for, *T, Wang is: mentioned as. Tuan honestly remove from= the: herd any /Reuter's' Pavifié Service.
Nerviee.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.