Macleod, continuing defence, again put before the Court the position as already outlined a: the lest hearing. Counsel affirmed that the purchaser of a business had the right to use the marks except the ease of a trade secret. as in the instance of the Chartreuse case saterser ts and when he could not represent himself selling that article to hit customfers. because he did not know the If the place of manufacture was made quite clear it would be Possible to have both manufacturers {who ecu sell their articles ax long the customer was not deceived wae dificult to nce how the we could restrain the other {rot setting in a third country.
Counsel went on to say that they would not be bound to print on their labels "suecesran." However if they put nothing on their labels to sig they were successors, the; Tight be restrained as the custom fers might be made to believe the business' was under the o management. "It was a. question:
showing change of ownership There had been. mo. actual care all. Cours with the present cave though there had been others ras in the case. of the Chartreuse ease and that of Muna Ca. in. France. eas necessary to. examine" the se case both in the House fof Appeal and the House of Lords. The "fact that. the monks stil retained their secret process could hot alter the legal effect of the Transfer of the butines. A' mere variation gf process was "not Traudulent. "Tt" wad, however, fraudulent if you called it by ite [ie Lordship—ts'a Manila name. cigar manufactured from Manila obaceo? What does the ordinary Manila cigar?
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.