The Archive · 1921

REPRESENTATION ON THE CoUNciL

During the period of my visit to Shanghai, the community, native and foreign, was much exercised over a question which has frequently vexed it in recent years, namely, the right of the Chinese taxpayers to representation on the Municipal Council—in other words, to a share in the direct government of the Settlement Young China's fervour, excitement and _—eloquence, and its—skilful use of the machinery of intimidation in dealing with the timid shopkeeping class, presented on this occasion no new features. There were the usual telegrams in all directions, the usual manifestos by all sorts of associations, real and imaginary, the usual passionate assertion of China's sovereign rights, accompanied by threats of strikes and personal denunciations. But as an example of windy agitation on a trackless sea of sentiment, there was something very significant, not only in Young China's handling of the matter, but in the sympathetic, not to say respectful, reception accorded to their views by officials and influential members of the foreign community. tives to put Young China firmly in its place: for it should have been self-evident that a claim to give the Chinese seats on the Council, as a matter of equity and based on their numerical strength, would give them, on the same grounds, a perfect right to absolute control.

The obvious course, whereby. alone the just claims of the Chinese could be reconciled with the facts of the situation (a course which should have been adopted when the Guilds proposed it in 1906), is for the foreign community to recognize and encourage a Chinese Consultative Committee, elected as the Chinese ratepayers may think fit to take its advice, whenever feast ible, in matters affecting purely Chinese interests, and to give all possible publicity to its representations, The essential need of the situation is machinery for the ventilation of the Lona-fide_grievances of the law-abiding Chinese community. Such grievances undoubledly t, but the professional agitator who plies his noisome trade under the protection of the municipality should be forcibly reminded that these grievances are as gossamer on the summer breeze as compared with the burdens borne by those who dwell in Chinese cities—"whose children are far from safety, whose harvest the hungry eateth up. and the robber swal-lowe th up their substance."

Tre Dancers oF ASYLUM.

The Chinese claim.o represeutation based on elementary justice is morally unanswerable; to deny it is morally impossible, since nine-tenths of the Settlement's revenues are collected from Chinese ratepayers. Unfortunately, however, the existence ofthe Settlement itself is equally indefensible on broad grounds of justice. It was originally established, and has ever since been maintained, by the law of the stronger, and because Chinese methods of administration could never provide the foreign trader with anything like security for life and property. For that matter, the whole principle of extraterritoriality can only be defended on grounds of political expediency, in themselves unjust. But if extraterritoriality goes. the Foreign Settlement goes also, not only as an object-lesson in efficient administration, but as a sanctuary for From the point of view of the Chinese Government (if ever it reaches a state of coherence such as shall enable it to maintain one), the protection which the self-governing Settlements of the Treaty Ports afford to political refugees and conspirators is likely to present a much more serious problem. The asylum found by the Provisional Government of the Repub-lie of Korea" in the French Settlement at Shanghai constitutes a precedent which might easily develop along lines fraught with real danger to the destinies of the Model Settlement. The path of wisdom for the City Fathers, looking to the future, must lie in barring all but purely local_polities and in preventing the Settlement from becoming an Alsatia and a stamping-ground for wild asses.

J. O. P. Buanp.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account