The Archive · 1925

Against Packing

"It is the duty of these business houses of ours," said Judge M. D. Purdy at the U.S. Court, on Tues day, "to observe the conditions of contracts and the courts functioning. ax they do must protect the contracting parties. If either fails he is to damages." "Gi ment for plaintiff Servanin v. the Murray Packing Ca. his Honour awarded plaintiff Tls. 5,040, in respect of a broken contract, defendant failing to deliver to Servanin 25 tons of hen yolk and approximately five tons of al-humeri in September last.

'At the close of the case, Mr. 'Schuhl, representing plainti the Judge referred to the North: China Hong List for the table of corresponding Chinese and foreign' weights and measures, pointing out that 16.80 piculs was the equivalent of one ton.

Mr, J. Reynard, a witness for plaintiffs, stated that he had entered into negotiations with one Henfnigsen, whose name appeared on. the company stationery, as sales manager, for the purchase of ego products, the price of the yolk to. be Tis? 18 per picul and the al-humeri Tls. 145 per picul, September} delivery.

Mr. Schuhl introduced eight exhibits pertaining to the agreement and confirmation thereof.

Mr. Worthington, for defendant, objected, stating ' that counsel {for plaintiff failed to prove that the signature was that of an agent, but his Honour overruled the objection. Continuing svitners stated that he, as a commission broker, resold the materials to J. H. Grein of London and when defendant did not deliver them he had go into the open market September and purchase identical seeds for prices ranging round Tis. to 24 and Tls. 175 per picul Corroborative evidence as to Sept-_ ember prices was given by Mr. Rene Mazet, export, manager Racine & Ca., and Mr. T. K, Chu, owner of an egg factory in Honan province.

Mr. Worthington's motion for dismissal of the action being over~ roled, he called Mr. P. R. Murray, managing director of the Murray Packing Ca. Witness stated hat Hennigsen had no authority to sign contracts as sales manager, the sole Fight being vested in "himself, though when he went to Hongkong to secure further business, he de-agated that right to Messrs. Hen-and P. A. Ismail conjointly. He. called upon plaintiff in August on his return, and when the latter would not advance him packing credits, he informed him that the contract could not be considered, which plaintiff refused to admit, In reply to Mr, Schuh! he stated that his company was not position to deliver the products on Joly 21, the date of the contract, Tudgiment was given, as stated.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account