The Archive · 1928

Opium in Shanghai

Mar, 5.

The communication from the National Anti-opium Association, which we published on Friday February 2, is an interesting ustration of how history repeats itself. As.a matter of fact, Ro petition for the legalizing of opium sales has been sent in yet, but there is no reason to suppose it may not be. Possibly the Anti-Opium Association spoke prophetically. The sale of opium in the Settlement, if granted to a syndicate, would be one of the most lucrative monopolies ever conceded to a trading company. That. there are those whose mouths water at the thought of such a prize being within the possibility of achievement we need not doubt. Neither have we much doubt that the possibility of such a petition being presented has been discussed by some of those already interested in the ilicit trade in opium. We can imagine the arguments with which the petition would be backed up, First, the Council would reap a rich harvest as its share of the profits by a heavy tax on the monopoly. Two million taels per annum is the figure suggested and, in these evil days, such a sum, certainly, Yooks attractive, Secondly, it is, admittedly, impossible to prevent smuggled opium from being Yatailod in the Settlement. Outside the limits there is hardly pretence of concealment the traffic in the forbidden opium suppression was an impossibility. They agreed to do the next best thing and legalize what they could not abolish. They may have taken a wrong course and it is arguable that would have been letter to have continued to fail rather than to cover with the cloak of legitimacy a traffic inherently vicious Who would dare to dogmatize on this point? We know what) did happen and the evils the opium trade brought on the country; we have no wish to minimize these in the least. But what the result would have been if something had been done that ras not done, is beyond the wit Jof man to declare. We are only leon cerned to justify the intentions of the men who did what they sincerely thought was the vest thing they could dd in the lcircumstancex in which they placed and to express. a. 8, who think' their own rectitude shines clear-jest when they are denouncing the alleged shortcomings of their countrymen, will see that little ness and not magnanimity is the subconscious motive that impels to such action. We are perfectly jeertain that the British Government will never alter or even modify the attitude it has taken jup on the opium question. There} is no politician, let alone statesman, in Great Britain who would have the hardihood to propose a change or even a qualification lot that policy of absolute condemnation of the use of narco-

We are assured on good authority, that, in many places, the sale of opium is the main source of revenue for the maintenance of some of the standing armies with which China cursed. Since this is so, why should not facts be recognized, ud the sale of opium, which it is impossible to prohibit, be conducted under proper safeguards and regulated by law?

No one would deny that there much sound common sense in these arguments. They were precisely the reasons that led the British and Chinese plenipotentianess to conclude the treaty of Hoomun Chao which legalized the sale of opium in China after the war of 1840-2. This was the treaty which gave a handle to many uninformed persons, who accused Britain of "foreing opium on China at the cannon's mouth." How many excellent missionaries, entirely ignorant of the facts, but burning with zea] that exceeded both their Smowledge and discretion,, expanded on the iniquities of their own Government in compelling the helpless Chinese to submit to an unjust treaty. The truth was that the Chinese Government of those days had made an honest, but entirely ineffective, effort to' suppress the opium trade. It failed to achieve its object because the smugglers were humorous and well organized, the majority of, the officials were venal and covetous and the Funners, then as now, the least reliable' police force in the world. The American Government, with a thousand times the resources that the Chinese emperor of that day could command, has failed, so far, to' suppress Doot-legging and we have seen, since' the elimination of the British trade in opium, China's illicit traffic grow to Buch pro-tie drugs for any other than medicinal purposes. Much might depend oh where a petition for licensing the opium trade might Jcome from. But there can be no doubt that our own Municipal Council is as firmly determined {to adhere to its policy of the total prohibition of the sale of opium within Settlement limits as even its sternest critics could desire.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account