The Archive · 1928

Northern Mandarins Here

One immediate and tangible result of this reaction is the increasingly, large numbers of North-fern mandarins who appear Shanghai and who represent every Northern political and military fife. One sees them in the hotels and restaurants; one meets them at parties; one sees them in the streets." Former Ministers and Vice-Ministers of Peking governments have been passing through Shanghai in open freedom and some fof them are known to have been in conference with those who dominate Nationalist polities at the present time. The importance of their presence has to be measured not only terms of a possible understanding between Nanking and Peking, but from the standpoint of the view of the present Nanking Government, Te is perhaps necessary to give something of the history of the reaction. The December conferences in Route de la Tour resulted in the elimination of the Communists, the semi-Communists, the Left Wing Kuomintang, the Right Wing and the Western Hills Conference group. In practical terms this means that the extreme Conservatives and tio extreme Radicals have been driven out of the Party and that most of the individuals belonging to these groups have gone travelling else-[where than in China.

Politically, the balance of power fell into the hands bf group of men, the leaders of whom have daring the past decade or two, been open and avowed anarchists, Their intellectual heritage has been denunciation of the orderly processes of Government, They have advocate ed_@ policy of political and social Taisder faire and their opposition to the Communists during the three yeara was not based so much upon an antagonism to Soviet Russia and its social and economic creed, og to the normal antipathy of anarchists to the highly despotic and centralized system of government devised by Soviet Russia. They are now all powerful and the leader of the group, Mr. Li Shih-tsong, is undoubtedly the political master of the present Nanking Government.

The Two Student Groups As a result of this mastery there isa definite division among the administrative personalities in Nanking. What might be called the Anglo-American returned student element is exceedingly unfriendly to the present dominating political forces there. The Anglo-American element constitutes what might be termed the modern progressive party in the Kuomintang. This roup ig not organized as a political party; it lacks, to a very definite degree, an ability to operate political movements; it devotes itself to tasks of administration and grumbles over the political incompetence of its masters, Opposed to it are the Franco-Japanese returned students who seem to have a greater ability in political manipulation, but who have not been so successful in the conduct of administrative offices. This latter group definitely supports the anareliists and together they are respon-for a reaction which could have only one of two results, either the recrudescence of the power of the Communist Party of China or the moral collapse of the Kuomintang, through its intimate association with mandarism.

The reactionaries cling to many of the features of the Radical Kuomintang. They believe that there can be only one Party in China and that that Party must control the Government, but they differ from the Kuomintang in that they include, as partisans, man} individuals who are not tried members of the Kuomintang and who are therefore capable of serving other parties in the North while holding office in the Kuomintang. they come down to business.

In other words, the reactionaries are quite prepared to adopt the political opportunism of the North while at the same time keeping their soldiers employed in a hazardous military expedition, Too Much Repression In the matter of administration the reaction compromises in every respect with a_politico-commercial and mandarin element in nationalist territory. They believe that an outivard semblance of order justifies the suppression of every organ of public opinion which reflects the attitude of the masses, whom they themselves have influenced to think and act politically. They have for-hidden mass meetings of the people ind-are intolerant to all forms of dissent, Thay have not only driven the Communist Party of China underground, shut even within the Kuomintang, differences of opinion fare regarded as intolerable and are driven underground. Their anti-Communism has become so marked that they seem to be prepared to effect no change in the current status of China's international rela~ tions except such changes as might end the misunderstanding between the Nationalist Government and the foreigners, It is, perhaps, not the place of a foreigner who has, for three years, been constantly "denouncing the Communist Purty of China, to" criticize unfavourably such a policy. Yet this reactionary policy is, in my opinion, more dangerous, at' the present time than an open and frank Communist policy, for it is unreal and untrue and does not represent the corns of opinion of large, articulate elements, among the Chinese people and it can only result in lulling the foreigners and the conservative Chinese into a false security,, from which the recovery may prove to be exceedingly costly.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account