"Hem Cuoseo Manoa. Putnam "Weale. London: Siscmiian & Cor In his latest novel Mr. Putnam Weale has rather fallen between two stools, He has chosen wisely in taking for the background of his story the period when Peking was tottering under the revolution of the autumn of 1911. It is a time which novelists and writers generally seem a little to have neglected, and Mr. Putnam Weale is. admire [ably equipped to make effective use of it, as this novel shows. Like all hhis writing, "Her Closed Hands" is eminently readable, But one cannot help wishing there had been more of the background and less of the foreground. The latter is occa-pied by a group of foreigners revolving about the usual "eternal trinnglo" and it must be confessed that one is not too much interested in their story. On the other hand the Chinese scenes are presented with all the skill and insight which Mr. Putnam Weale possesses to 30 marked a degree. Wang the Ninth is a truly delightful character of whom one would have liked a great deal more. It is a pity that during the most important part of his life, when he passes from vagabond to commander of a revolutionary regiment, the transition has to tuke while foreigners hold stage.
From the opening chapters one expected that the Great House and the intrigues of the old lumber merchant would have played a greater part in the working out of the story, and certainly one would have liked more of the lumber merchant's daughter. These remarks are really a compliment to Mr, Putnam Weale since there are so few foreigners who can write with the knowledge and sureness of touch about the Chinese sat he possesses, Of the foreigners {in this story one suspects that some may be actual portraits, especially, Dr. Kettling, who, by the way, is the author of some remarkable passages
[book he is writing) on the psycho (ssu to be an extract from a logy of the Chinese. But perhaps the most illuminating paragraph is that which describes the feelings of 'a houseboy when the heroine has Just hurried Into at night, regardless of conventions, to the house of the hero, a bachelor, to consult him about a letter which has provoked a crisis between herself and hor husband, This is the paragraph.
"The servant went, out at
loved. the door, seeept Buse throwing' back elle Renee Nomen" ploughing their way don Sib Dred Shieh sever tow the Blade The last words in particular might be commended as. the explanation of so int misunder-Standing and. friction "between foreigners and the Sons of Han.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.