The Archive · 1921

Chinese Public Opinion

To the Editor of the "Norra-Cuina Dairy News."

Sir,—I observe, in a leading article contained in the ''Herald" of February 5, that you say I "scoff at the idea of an active public opinion in China, outside the Treaty Ports." May I point out that this statement is not borne out by anything which I have written on the subject? What you really mean, I think, is that I have scoffed (and still scoff) at the idea that Young China's political and intellectual activities constitute "an active public opinion" capable of representing the mind of the masses, and that I therefore regard their ready-made Republic as a snare and a de-lusian.

That there is, and always has been, 2 force of public opinion in China capable of expressing itself very clearly in case of need, none can deny. What I do deny is, that the nature and direction of that force (which is the fundamental spirit of China's civilization) can be suddenly and _radically changed by a revolution, or, indeed, by anything but a slow process of evolution extending over many generations.

It is obvious that, during the turmoil of the past ten years, the influence of "western-learning," and all that goes with it, has spread fast and far among the class which rules, or aspires to rule, the country; nevertheless I venture to maintain that it is of its nature transient and exotic and that (as I wrote ten years ago) Young China ideals and projects of government are foredoomed, because they involve the creation of a new social and "political structure utterly un-"suited to the character and "traditions of the race; because it "ig contrary to all experience that "a people cut off from its deep-"rooted beliefs and habits of life, "should develop and retain a "vigorous national consciousness."

T firmly believe in the vigorous national consciousness of the Chinese people, and I also believe that, in duc season, it will find its natural expression in "an active public opinion," which will relegate to silence and obscurity many of the fantastic phenomena which now disturb its vision and its peace.

I am, etc, J. O. P. Buanv.

Thatched House Club, London, March: 23.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account