The Archive · 1911

Crown Colony of Hongkong

The objection rests pon the general rale in common law pleading that the exclusive right of action rests in the party who holds the strict legal title The petition in this cause recites the claimant as "liquidator," " term little koowo in American law, but which an-doubtedly corresponds to the office of receiver familiar to American jorisprudence. While ther some conflict of authority in di American javisdictions as to the right of action reatiog ins reosiver, the tendency is to recognize euch right, But in the present case the petition alleges that the corporate foreign corporation and that the rlsintiff has been daly appointed liquidator of that corporation Of course, such appointment mast ba been made, if at all, in obedience to the provisions of some foreign law and asthe resalt of process in some foreign Court, In order to perfect the pleading and give such notice as onder general rules the defendant is entitled to have, it would seem essential that the petition should recite not only the general fact of such appointment bat the particular foreign Court in which the proceedings were bad and the date of sach appointment and the statute or under which such appointment was justified. This faller statement appears to the Court to be necessary in order that the defendant may be placed in position to raise such objections as to hi to the Haodicdon of the Court or to the leg effectiveness of the proceedings therein taken, Assuming that the first paragraph of the petition should be amended as suggested, it would spear to the Court to be immaterial whether the claimant in this case is recited as Eric M. Ross liquidator of the company or the company be recited as by Erie Ross, liquidator.

'A greater precision in the petition appears to be necessary, eapscially because of the fact that the corporation is a foreign corporation and controlled and begelated by the provisions of foreign law.

The other grounds for demurrer are more generally stated as relating to Jack of precision and fallaces of statement.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account