May 8.
Quite apart from agreement or disagreement with the Municipal Economy Committee's report, congratulations are due to them in full measure for the clarity and comprehensiveness of their work. Here they tell us exactly what they had to consider, how they considered it and why they make the recommendations they do. A neat synopsis of expenditure sets out all the figures essential for an understanding of the case, We may not agree with the conelusions, but we would venture to say that we have never seen 1 better constructed report. If the remaining sections are up to the same level, something may yet be done to check the mor: dinate growth of municipal expenditure. Two points in the general recommendations which deserve early attention are the advantages of engaging Chinese nurses and the case for a larger contribution from the French Concession to the upkeep of International Settlement hospitals, The loss incurred in serving patients who are residents of the Concession is Ts, 30,000 year and this involves a moral claim which we cannot believe the French Council would repudiate, As regards Chinese nurses, no disparagement is meant of British or American. But it is obviously much cheaper to got nurses on the spot than to bring them from Europe or America; and those who have been under Chinese nurses know how good they can be.
Survoying the whole: field of hospitals in Shanghai the Committee found themselves confronted with two serious and inevitable stumbling-blocks: the Chinese Isolation Hospital is stinetly dangerous," dry rot, decay and leakages rife, and must speedily be rebuilt at an estimated cost of Tls. 275,000, not including a lease of, say, Tls. 35,000 for temporary pre: mises. And the Foreign Isolation Hospital is an indispensible expense in respect of which no changes are recommended" although there is an annual loss on its working of Tls. 89,- 550. There is also a demand for a new Chinese and Indian Police Hospital to cost Tls. 175,- 000. But this the Committee reject altogether. Their solution is to close the maternity and children's blocks of the Victoria Nursing Home as such and convert them into an Indian Police Hospital. © The main block of the V.N.H. would be converted into a Chinese Police Hospital with provision for gaol cases. The Mental Ward would continue. The private nursing staff would be discontinued; but there should be a reserve of nurses in the general adrtinistration who "when not required for emergency work in Muni: cipal Hospitals" would" be available for private services. By
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.