The Archive · 1921

The Wireless Dispute

May 7.

Tue signature by the Chinese Government of the contract with the American Federal Wireless Telegraph Ca., on January 6 of this year, has led to a triangular dispute in which American, Japanese and Chinese interests are involved. Going back to first causes the origin of the dispute.may be found in the agreement signed by the Ministry of the Navy and Messrs. Mitsui Ca. in February, 1918. By this instrument the Chinese Government allowed the company to erect a great wireless station, capable of communicating with Japan, Europe and America, at a capital cost of £536,267, the sum being repayable in thirty equal yearly instalments. The agreement itself does not appear to have given the Japanese company any wireless monopoly in China, but this state of affairs was radically changed by a declaration on March 5 attached to the agreement, by which it was declared that during the term of thirty years no other party shall be allowed to erect a similar wireless telegraph station communicating telegraphically with Japan, Europe and America, neither may the Chinese Government itself erect an installation.'' Though it has been claimed that this was designed to protect a young undertaking from competition likely to make it unremunerative, there can be little doubt but that the Japaness interests regarded it as conveying to them an out-and-out monopoly for the term of the agreement, not excluding others from erecting wireless stations as such, but preventing the install tion of other plant capable of worldwide communication. In the same year, October 9, a contract was eatered into between the Marconi Wireless Telegraph Ca. and the Chinese Government for the erection of three wireless stations at Kashgar, Urumchi and Lanchowfu with a guaranteed daylight range of 700 miles—obviously domestic stations as distinct from that contemplated under the Sino-Japanese agreement.

Then came the agreement with the American Federal Wireless Telegraph Ca. for the erection of four stations, at Canton, Shanghai, Eeking and Harbin, all of high power and as large as any in the world, at a reported price of gold $4,200,000. The instellations were to be operated under the Telegraph Administration -with foreign supervision and were to revert to China in ten years—a somewhat more favourable arrangement than that under the contract with Japan. Naturally such an agreement roused opposition from the outset. It was argued by the Japanese that their rights under the contract of February, 1918, were very seriously impaired, and they demanded cancellation of the new agreement, basing their demand upon the declaration already referred to. The American response was that the arrangement with Mitsui & Ca. was in direct contravention of the stipulations of the Sino-American Treaty of 1858 and the Chinese could not, therefore, grant any exclusive monopoly to the Japanese company. An argument more directly for Japanese consideration was also advanced, namely, that both she and the United States had invariably concurred in the view that efforts to obtain special privileges by one nation which abridged the rights of the subjects of others were to be discouraged, and that in face of the existing inadequacies of the Pacific cable communications the Japanese Government could not desire to oppose a project for supplementing these facilities. The Japanese rejoinder was that the declaration was designed to prevent the multiplication of wireless stations which might prevent their own installation from paying its way.

There are, therefore, two aspects to this question: first the insistance on the maintenance of the protection given to the Japanese station, although by the fine division of hairs it is denied to be a monopoly; secondly, the insistance of the United States that there is every sign that a monopoly has been wrongfully created and also that on the grounds of expediency it ought not to be insisted upon by the holders. The problem presents no inherent difficulties, viewed from a purely theoretical point of view. If the concession granted to the Mitsui Ca. is indeed bad in the light of the Sino-American Treaty of 1858, it cannot be binding upon the United States, and for that matter upon the Chinese Government vis-d-vis of the American Company. Indeed Art xxx of the Treaty of 1858 goes as far as is needed to support the American case. It says:

"The Contracting Parties hereby agree that should at any time the Ta-Tsing Empire grant to any nation, or the merchants or citizens of any nation, any right, privilege, or favour connected, either with navigation, commerce, political or other intercourse, which is not conferred by this Treaty, such right, privilege and favour shall at once freely enure to the benefit of the United States, its public officers, merchants and citizens."

Thus China could not grant a monopoly to Japan with regard to the wireless station it was to erect, and, the Treaty in question being public property, the Mitsui, Ca. must be regarded as having entered into the contract with its eyes open. Whether or not the contract with Japan is a shining example of Peking's commercial morality we do not propose to discuss. That it is bad as against the United States, there seems to be ample indication, for the Chinese Government cannot grant privileges, etc. to any one nation which do not immediately enure to the United States. There seems to be reason for America's attitude,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account