The Archive · 1928

Unanswerable Reply on All Points

Provisional Court a Test Case for Abolition of ritoriality The Provincial Government of ernment ever since this Court.came Kiangsu, failing in their second at~ into being. This is proved (1) by tempt to dismiss Judge Loo, have the telegraphic order issued by the again framed up five charges suid Government in reply to a re-against him before the Committee of quest by Dr. V. K. Ting (2) by the Disciplinary Punishment for Judi-petition to the said Government by cial Officials. The Committee which my predecessor in respect of the has recently been appointed by the qualification of judges for this Court Nanking Government, has com-(8) by the letter of recommendation municated the charges to Judge 1.00 by my predecessor Dr. Hey (Ex-and required him to file an answer hibits 1, 2, & 8) not later than July 3 as the fol-When the defendant assumed the lowing date has been fixed to office in May 1927, several judges examine the case by the said body. wished to resign. ' The defendant It will "be recalled that Judge did all he could to persuade them Loo, after receiving the order of to remain but of no avail. The petition to the Court was thus faced with lity of being paralysed sult of the resignation of the Md on Judges pending the appointment of around. that, dismissal since the ones. In order to avoid such Srder. of "October last year "was happening the defendant has deem-vetoed by the Nationalit Gov fed it necessary to appoint acting ent, no fresh charge has boon made Judges to tide over the difficulty and wai nat. him which would warrant at the same time made reeommendathe punishment of a dismissal. Action to the Provincial Government cordingly the Kiangou Government for confirmation. han preferred five charges, before the "Disciplinary Committee.

'Neither New nor Illegal hich four have been. digs 0 Bid endiges made in This procedure-is - not" new quite} 'October, 1927, sed on the fact that' Judes "Afth, which ie x new one, apart, from the fact that it was practice of my" predecessor an that until there is a new rule ti the Loo tu responsible for the. congestion of remanded cates, The contrary It te, quite legitimate to follow the existing practice. For the owing is Judge Loo's reply to there taking of such temporary measures charges, the full text of which a is quite in keeping with the peared in Monday's Toes) vernae existing rule which authorises ular papers. the President of a High Court is, however, believed In local to appoint acting judges whencoffcia lrcles that it la x foregone ever 4 Vacancy occurs. As the Conclusion. that the Nanking Dis-president of the Provisional Court is iplinary Committee cannot but concurrently the head of the Apfind Judge Loo guilty and that the pellate Court the defendant is at! proceedings will only be a matter Tenst entitled to claim the same of form to satisfy those who are. at power as a Chief Judge of hij fall logan-minded. For it is stated court. Again it was only a confidentially by' some days—the longest being about Chinese that the fortnight—atter these judges were Kiangsu Government appointed to act as interim judges ing heaven and to get a (which by the way was always ex-decision against Judge Loo, because pressly stated in the letter of their "face" must be saved at all appointment) and the delay was in costs. It is very significant that some cases inevitable and certainly a certain man called Chen Hoshen, not intentional. who was responsible for all "As to the accepting of the rethe trouble against Judge Loo and signation of some judges it was the Provisional Court generally when with regret that the defendant he was the Kiangsu Commissioner failed to retain their service, but of Justice and who is still a mem-such practice was followed by his bor of the Kiangsu Government, is predecessor (Exhibit 4) and in such. now appointed a member of the case the defendant has invariably' Disciplinary Committee which is to shed for the confirmation of the try the case against Judge Loo. rovineial Government, accordingly sent in As to the delay of submitting the written objection td the Nation letter of recommendation in the case. alist Government opposing Mr. of Judge Lu Wen-lan, was beau: Chen's appointment to the Com-that there was ait the time no vacant. mittee, but without ava ey until Judge Hsu Mo resigned and that Judge Lu was then still the Judge Loo's Reply Judge of the high Court in Canton Whereas the undersigned defendant in this disefplinary case has tioned by the Canton Court un received an order from your honour-after many "months. So before a able Committee stating that the vacancy occurred and the trans-'Ministry of Justice, bya petition ference was properly effected, Judge from the Kiangsu Provincial Gov-Lu could only'be made an acting ernment charging the defendant Judge here for the time being. This with having.acted in many cases Procedure was also followed by the contrary to his duties and neglect: former President Mr. Hsu in the ed hhis office And Whereas the de-case of appointment of Judges Shen fendant considers that the instances and Chung (Exhibit 5). adduced by the Kiangwu Provingial Government are nothing but results 'A Suggestion Quite Permissible of misunderstanding on the part. of 'U—Regarding the alleged inter-the Provincial Government; the ference with affairs outside the defendant therefore—rémpecttully scope of the Court. submits the following answer to the This charge was made because a Yatious charges for your conidernago the defendant had made ion. suggestion to the Provincial Gov-Regarding the appointment of ermment that a "Judicial Reform Sudges:—Discussion Committee" be formed According to the Agreement for to" undertake certain investigations the Rendition of the Mixed Court into mutters pertaining to the work-(Article 2 Paragraph G) the power ing of this Court and to make re-of appointment is no: doubt ye Jeomntendations therefor from time.

the Provincial Government, but to tithe with " view to making new power of recommending)' ssu: improvements. The idea was origiaappointment has been conferred ally conceived from the fact that. the President of this Court by Gov-according to, the report of the Joint

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account