IV. Regarding the alleged interference with the judge's decision:
This charge is instanced by the fact that during a discussion at the Judges' weekly conference on October 5, when the question whether in view of the crime wave then subsisting in Shanghai, "a severe sentence should be imposed in. the ease of highway armed robberies, was brought up the defendant had asked Judge Liang Jen-che if he would consider sufficiently adequate the sentence of 10 years imprisonment which he was going to pass on 4 highway armed robber who shot at the police constable, since such 4 sentence would mean the minimum of the minimum penalty according to the Criminal Code which would be Justifable only. when there -were
surely such a discussion cannot in mitigating rmataries. But any sense of the word be construed] to be interference with the decision of @ judge. In point of fact the resident of this Court is empower-by "the Rules and Reulations ofthe Shanghai Provisional Court (Art, 25) authorized by the Provincial Goy-tment to Teview all judgments, except in summary cases, prepared by the judges before they are delivered in Court. (Ex. 12). The defendant would consider himself to have neglected is duty had he failed to pay sufféient attention to the important judgment submitted for his approval or failed to Point out the mistakes found in any of these judgments; Had the defendant tried to alice the decision of a was t make a suggestion and it was made at a meeting of the judges. Although the defendant has rarely made use of the power conferred by law to alter the decision of other judges, he was obliged to Pay more attention to Mr, Liang. Jen-che's judgments which were often found faulty. fu one case, for instance, he acquitted an armed robber and yet confiscated his pistol while in another case he sentenced an accused to 3 years imprisonment. for one crime and another one year for a concurrent crime, but he ordered that the convict' shall serve the combined sentence for a yeat and three months only.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.