The Archive · 1928

Congestion at the Court

It is charged that the defendant responsible for the congestion of remanded cases. But what are the facts. It is true that the number of civil eases up to October 1927 was no less than 1174 and that of criminal eases was 440, but these eases were not accumulated during the defendants tenure of office. The number of cases on May 16, 1927 when the defendant took up his duty was 2261 civil cases and 230) criminal cases all pending for trial This figure may be verified by th Joint report submitted by the former President Hsu and the defendant himself to the Provincial Gov ernment. Then came the summer vacation during which very Iitile work could be done. Yet the judges were made to do extra work and 80 by October no less than 1086 civil cases and 1867 criminal eases have been disposed of apart from the new cases which were finished day by day. The reason why in October the number of cases pending was still "what it was" atated the October report is as follows (2). Firat of all there were then together only 6 court rooms for of us and for this reasons we has. tened to build 4 additional court rooms which, however, were not ready for use until sometime after October. This fact alone: is ull [elent t0 account dor. the digiculty in expediting the clearing up of thone old cases, (2) Secondly, most of these old cases were Mixed civil ceases in which the presence of the conaalat official of the country con. cerned is required and in" con. iuequence the hearing cannot be set freely without any regard to the convenience of the parties concerned. Thia difficulty which is not experienced in other Chinese courts has to be taken into account when the work of the court is to be properly appreciated. (3) Lastly, in these remanded cases were included those which have been left over from the former Mixed Court. There were cases adjourned on a certain condition and until such condition was fulfilled they could not be disposed of.

spite of all these difficulties we have since then made a supreme effort to reduce the number of remanded eases and by May this year the number of civil cases boon Teduced to 608, and that of criminal cases to 221 or an average of 40 remanded eases per judge (Bx. 18). And these are at present in course of trial and not adjourned sine die. They are therefore eases which cannot be finished at once but require further investigation. According to the latest report of the Chief Clerk of this court, the number of pending cases for this month has deen further reduced almost to the possible minimum (Ex. 14). The truth of his statement is borne out! by the fact that the Commigsioner of Police of the Shanghai Municipal Gouncil who has most to do with this Court in his annual report for 1927 published @ few months ago praised the work of this Court as being efficient and progressing. The Court is moreover at present enjoying the respect and "confidence of both Chinese and "oreign residents in the Settlement and this is due chiefly to the steadfast and painstaking effort of the judges in reducing the remanded cases to the lowest possible extent. A congestion. of eases can only be aald to exist when the Court receives more ceases! than it can disposed of that at the end of every month there's a balance of, unfinished eases. Bat this is not the ¢ase with this Cosrt. Sines the defendant "came the fiuintber of cases concluded every, received by result the Court and by the former edninatr tion was made possible.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account