The Archive · 1921

The Boxer Indemnity

June 3.

Dourine the past few days an appeal has been made to the Shanghaj public on. behalf of a great British missionary body, whose finances have been cruelly hit by circumstances wholly outside its own control. That appeal stands on its own merits, it belongs to the noblest order human endeavour and we hope and believe it will not fail of its object. But there is one aspect of the work of the C.M.S. which is bound up with a subject very near to many minds and of vital importance to the British people. Much of the business of the C.M.S. is educational, just as is that of other missionary organizations. Their schools may be found all over the country, and when the work they do is examined, either by a personal visit on some holiday trip away from Shanghai or through the medium of annual reports, it is difficult to say whether we feel most admiration for the achievements won with such slender resource s or regret that their means do not allow of their er-larging their field of operation. Most especially is it deplored by those who will have seen to what we are leading up, that there are so few opportunities of sending on the boys of these Schools to complete their education at a university. We make no apology for returning to this "subject because a chance is now offered of remedying the defect. Only it is necessary to look ahead -and to act quickly or the chance may slip by, never to return.

In the series of articles by the Rev. G. G. Warren on British Chinese Universities and what other nations have done in this direction, which we published a month ago, he devoted a special chapter to the possibility of getting some of the Boxer Indemnity found and equip universities in China. Mr. Warren wrote very frankly on the question of this indemnity, which is often spoken of with more sentimentality than sense.

The Boxer Indemnity (he truly says) was.in no wise excessive considering the crime for which it was a punishment; it was not excessive when China's power to pay it all ig taken into account. The change of government from Manchu to Chinese is no better reason for absolution from the results of Manchu deeds than is the change from Hohenzollern to Republican excuse for averting an indemnity from Germany.

It may be added that the amount exacted by Great Britain, namely sixteen and a half millions sterling, represented an absolute minimum, after the most rigid scrutiny and cutting down of all claims, and that considerably more might have been required without injustice. At the same time, as Mr. Warren said, the war has made a difference. We have seen from the newly concluded, Sino-German agreeme™i that, so far from Germany's getting any more indemnity from China, she is to pay one to her. No further Boxer indemnity, it is safe to say, will be paid to Austria or to Russia, and everybody knows what use, in China, America caused to be made of a part of her claim. We do not suggest that Great Britain should remit what is still due to her, but we certainly believe that she would be well advised to apply generous part of it to founding universities for Chinese in China.

The amount still owing to Great Britain is £9,740,000, payment being spread over another twenty-two years. It will be remembered that these payments were suspended for five years when China entered the war, and are accordingly due to recommence next spring. Clearly, then, no time must be lost in pressing upon the Home Giovernment the claim for a system of British-Chinese universities. It is not only to educational workers in China that the need for such a scheme and the desir ability of realizing it out of the Boxer Indemnity appeals. At the first meeting in November, 1919, of the British Chambers of Commerce a resolution, on kindred if not identical lines, was passed. The China Association has, we believe. made a similar recommendation: and it has further been advocated *t Home by newspapers so widely, dissimilar in their views on most topics as the ''Daily Mail'' and the Westminst Gazette."'

There is of course divergence of opinion as to whether the money should not be spent om travelling scholarships, to send Chinese to Britain; while others hold that all efforts should be concentrated on persuading Chinese of the centre and north to go to Hongkong. But the trend of opinion is less favourable to travelling scholarships than formerly, if only because of the much smaller number of men who can thus benefit. And in practice it is not easy to persuade Chinese of the Yangtze that Hongkong is not too remote for their song. Besides, if one university is not enough for England, it certainly is not enough for China, where, only for a beginning, Shanghai, Hankow and Tientsin all ought to have their universities. If the British Government will help in the way indicated (and surely the amount -receivable each year is not so vast that it might not be spared) British mercantile firms will contribute as they have done in Hongkong. To expect the latter to shoulder the whole burden is unfair,.because the project is truly a national one, and indeed would, be quite beyond them. In short, with some of the indemnity money the thing can be done, but not without. It is earnestly to be hoped that the tremendous possibilities latent in this great project will be represented at Home with the success that it so thoroughly deserves.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account