I read a few days ago some pleasantly ironical remarks by Sir Basil Thomson, Chief of the Special Department of Scotland Yard, concerning Sherlock Holmes, writes Mr. Wilfred Whitten. They were made in the course of an address to the Royal Society of Arts. Sir Basil is reported to have said I have often asked myself, when I have had a particularly difficult problem to solve, what Sherlock Holmes would have done in such a case. I imagine him, for instance, examining with his piercing gaze a bit of mud on a gate—the only clue to a crime.
I see him go to a cupboard where he keeps samples of the mud of every street. in London. He scrutinizes each sample intently, and ponders for the space of a few seconds. Presently he turns to Dr. Watson, who is standing in open-mouthed wonder beside him, snd, with a significant puff at his pipe, says casually "Watson—I_am now going out td arrest the Archbishop of Canterbury A Great Crime Expert.
This brought back to me an interesting editorial experience. Nearly 20 years ago, when the Sherlock Holmes stories were being read and talked about everywhere, it ocourred to me that would be interesting to obtain the best Scotland Yard opinion of Sir Conan Doyle's hero, I wrote to the late Sir Robert Anderson, who two years earlier had retired from his post as Head of the Criminal Investigation Department. Hardly hoping for results, I was astonished when Sir Robert Anderson's card was handed to me next morning and was followed by the great criminal expert himself. Sir Robert sat down and at once began to talk. Hoe had been interested. I saw a keen and kindly old gentleman who locked like a super-detective by not looking like one at all. Still there was that in his eye which one could connect with the penetralia of the Yard. There was more, I think, in his looks that one could connect with his wide social and religious interesta, and his theological writings. For Sir Robert Anderson was a man of great intellect and of strong and upward-looking faith.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.