The Archive · 1925

A Wild Scheme

A youth named Alexander gave evidence supporting plaintiff's story. {He said that at first defendant drove the car at a very fast pace and then slowed down to about 15, {mites an hour, which was the pace [they were travelling when the motor: cycle crashed at the turning into Dent Road. the motor cycle, which was con-that plaintiff? was unable to control In answer to Mr. Priestwood, witness said the motor car took the sequently overturned. Plaintiff ssu bend at that speed. tained a broken collar bone, and the A. motor engineer of some years' effects of the accident were such experience next told the court that that his ability to work or gain. a livelihood for himself were per-the idea of towing a motor cycle in this way seemed to him to be the manently impaired, wildest thing he had heard of. It! would be dangerous at any speed.

Excessive Speed Denied The cycle would wobble on any Defendant, in his answer, stated change being made in the speed and that he instructed plaintiff and an would incline to an angle when assistant to push the motor cycle toking a corner. back to the garage, but. on plain Mr. Priestwood—The fact that tift's "suggestion and at hia own this cycle was towed safely for request, and on his. representation a mile and a half prior that he could ride a motor eyel accident is proof the method is not he was allowed to attach it to the: itself dangerous? car to be towed back, Defendant, Witness—I might jump from that} drove the ear, but denied negligent: now to the ground now without or that he drove at an excessive being hurt. I might do it to-1 speed, and in turn contended that T think they row and be killed. the cycle was overturned because were lucky to get round one corner, of plaintiff's want of skill in con-without an accident. trolling it. In towing, plaintiff was aware of and agreed to run the A Doctor's Criticism of Hospital risk (if any) attached thereto. The Treatment broken collar bone was admitted, but other injuries or damages were Dr. Hoblachkin, engaged denied, private practice and also at the The accident occurred in Mi General Hospital (where the plain-ay tiff was treated after the accident) 1923, and Mr, Badeley explain said he examined him last month the delay in bringing the action and found that his left shoulder ws due to the fact that plaintitt ws slightly deformed, that there was unable to pay any fees and could jan injury to the Tung, and that the not find a solicitor who would take {broken collar bone had not been the ease up as a speculation. He: went back into plaintiffs employ. repenly set. 'There' appeared to have been some negligence in the and did light work, but his injured treatment of plaintif; and witness uurm got steadily worse, Comment did not think an English doctor would ing on the suggestion that plain-Was aware of the risk and con-have treated an English patient in the same way, nor would & Russian sented to it, counsel said that the! for a Russian patient, fact that a man did a thing rather than lose his job was not evidence 'You do not speak accord it to of consent. There must be "real" consent. my experience," his Lordship obsery-Witness expressed Plaintiffs' Story the opinion that the result of the injury'

Plaintiff, in his evidence, stated i's working ability had been that he was an experienced mechanic {impaired by 60 per cent. end held -an automobile school di-eross-examination by Mr. loma. In April, 1923, he went) Priestwood, witness that into defendant's employ at $50 a plaintiffs inability to make fall use. month, and on the first of the fol-of his left arm was due to imperfect. lowing month the accident occurred Joining of the collar bone fracture. (as described in the statement of; Shanghai was not a village, and it) duim above). Before starting off should have been possible to set the fon the cycle, witness suggested to defendant that he should not drive fast, receiving a reply, angrily spoken, "I know how to drive a car.

Witness demonstrated the extent of the injury to his lett arm. by attempting to lift a law book, which he was only able to raise a few: inches. He had been advised that his left lung was also affected by the accident. In April of last your he was offered a position at Hankow at a salary of $150 a month, on two years' contract, but had to Tefuse it on. account of the accident.

In cross-examination by Mr. Priest wood, witness said that five or six turnings were safely taken on the way to the garage before the ae. cident happened. There was 'n> were certain such fractures which could not possibly be set in perfect alignment, but this was not! tone of them. Inabili plete arm was the muscles. Witness did not agree [with Dr. Bolton that the fractured collar bone was now stronger than the uninjured one and that plaintiff could freely use his left arm, Nor did he agree with Dr. Nield that while the anatomical result setting was not perfect, from a functional poing- of view it was ex: cellent and should be no bar to his working. In witness's opinion, plaintiff's present condition was due to unsuccessful treatment of the injury in May, 1923.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account