Q—Can you tell the story of Q—You also used the words what happened that. afternoon? "My opinion is", with respect to A—I left home about 1 o'clock pistol bullet.' Have you seen' and arrived at the corner of Nan-any pistol bullet wounds? king Road and Sincere's a little AAT have seen many. past 3. There were many people 'Q—So that with respect to pistol there but, as it was a Saturday. bullets, you agree with me, bu afternoon, and a holiday, 1 took with respect to rifle bullets, you no notice until I got in front of the merely understand that there is Sing Sing Ca. T then saw some very little difference. Let us con. sider a rifle bullet. If it should tudes "with banners in their Also, some handbills, and barm. hands trying to make speeches. strike a bone and the bullet should enter from the back and come out] in front. Applying the same_prin-plies were falling on the ground, picked one up, but it was torn oipleon which weare in agreement, land I threw it away. When I reached us regards pistol shots, would not the front door of the Dong Chang the bullet from tie rifle shatter Bicycle Ca. I saw some students the bone more seriously in front arrested by the Police. I went to 'A—The modern rifle, 1 believe: see what the matter was. I never is +o powerful that vhot at a smal thought it might be such a serious slistanee, I do not think there is All the people at the difference. lo were pushing forward Inasmach ay you have not Jand those in front wanted to re-thud experience with rifle shot, you treat. Twas pressed and surround-would not be dogmatic on' that led by the crowd. I was just about point! to turn buck, when T heard firing A—No, I would not be dogmatic and fell to the ground. When I Q-Since the Police testimony got up, I touched my back with' has stated there. were about 40 my hand and saw blood. I took' rifle shots, you would not be dog-a riesha and went direct to the! antic at all as to whether the shots; hospital. am the one that a doctor: were in the front or back? referred to as having been grazed.
A—I would not say they were Assessor:- What was he trying all rifle shots. I am only speak-to do when he was shot ing of the wounds, A—At that time, T had no in-"This concluded evidence tention to go forward. I was crushed by the crowd and had no of Dr. Davenport), {free movement.
Bvidence of Wei Ching Ding, (accused), unemployed boatnian ssessor:- Was he facing the aged 27.
Police or the other wa; A—I was facing the New, World.
Mngistrate:- Let tell his Q—Then the Police were in story ax to how ko got wounded.
'A—At 3 o'clock, I was at Lloyd front of him if he wax looking to-Road corner, coming along Nan-wards the Police, how could they shoot him in the back?
King Roa. 'I went to the comer A—At the time I heard the of Yunnan Road, just opposite Laura Station. [saw lots of peoing, I fell down on the ground._ T was senseless.
1 stood there for a cun-Sderable. time, did not see Q—If he is telling the truth, how could he be shot in the back? any person making speeches. 1 tid hing except the A—L vas standing in front of the 0 ncere's. Taw Dong Chang Ca.
3 or 4 foreign policemen coming Q—Did you have your lack to with lots of people to the Station saw to lines of policemen, the A—My back was against the first Iie of Sikhs and the second front door of the Dong Chang Ca. me C.iree, standing outside the there?
Q—How Jong was he standing tation gate. I was wounded at the time of the firing. I thought 'A—Ahout 20 minutes. The the bullet must have already lerowl was so large that 'I could passed through someone else's not get out of it. body b fore rca: hing mine, because Q—there was a large crowd al the force was not very strong. I the way from Sincere's, and yet wore a long lined gown and a short he ernie from Sincere's to the Sta-yeat, and the bullet penetrated all tion and he wants us to believe, clothing and mace a small hole the crowd was so thick that he {could not know whether the) leonid not get out of it again? ballet was inside my body or not, Did he see the Police armed 1 saw blood and put a -handker-with rifles? chief to it. saw over the shoulders of the others, 20 or more in number.
Q—Did' you hear anybody shouting "Stop"?
'A—There was such a crowd did not take any notice.
Q—Did you hear any shouting?
A—There was some shouting but I did not know the meaning.
(This concluded the evidence of this accused).
Dr. Mei said all the others Jadmitted they were students and; with the exception of two from the "Tong Tuli Medical, School, they were from the Shanghai University.
Rssessor:- Did they go out jon any definite instructions from anyone this afternoon Dr. Mei:- No, they had no def-mite instructions. My instructions are that they all went on their own The Court stated that a lot of] evidence had been allowed merely because the Court thought it would be best to let it indin order to allow people to air their views, but the Court was not a Court of Jenquiry into the action taken by the Police in dispersing this crowd Jand, therefore, argument should be confined to the evidence put in to prove and rebut this charge, only.
Each Counsel was allowed 10 minutes in which to sum up.
Mr. Ho Fei, through his inter. prefer, said that he had two answers to the allegations made by the prosecution. He would sta hhis arguments against. the prosefsecution's arguments first.
The prosecuting attorney alleged that the students were under the influence o& the Bolsheviks, Jand he had also said that there ere books of a Bolshevik nature in the school and that letters had been received from Germany. According to the Chinese idea the translation of this word was [that it was a kind of adjective, describing the terrible behaviour of the "Reds" of Russia. Accord ing to the Chinese translation of the word, it meant that ax xoon fas they wanted to do anything, [they wanted to try and kill other people.
With regard to the books i the school, it was a kind of refer. lence library which was not hibited by any country, and with regard to the letter from' Germany, was only a personal letter which Jonly said. something about reve lution, There was nothing in the letter about Bolshevism, there-
the slightest proof of Bolshevism. fore, he maintained, there was not With rogand to the action of the Police, this was an action they] could have taken only when it wax absolutely necessary.
According to the law, it was only if the students were going to kill the Police that the Police could Kill the students. Six minutes before the firing, the Police were still able to use their power.
With regard to the defendants in the dook, there were two kinds. One kind was the young] patriotic student who wanted to go out and let the people know about this shooting. With regard to this kind of lecture, it was common in every country, not only in Chi With regard tothe methods they
mouths and literature. If the olent. only used their ised, these were net man way
Police had not done too much, they would only have given the students some words of advice and ithe thing could easily have been finished. Ne he second class of people in the dock was those who had been wounded and sent to the Police Station from the Hospital, If they had been offending the Pol-fee rules, the Police would have arrested them before that. Their [wounds had been caused by the Police. and it was not right that they should be charged just be-Jeause they had been wounded. Whatever charges there were, there must be some sort of proof and against these men there was no [proof at all. Not only had they not, committed any crime, but the Police were responsible for dam.
Dr.
1 will try to keep. within 10. minutes, Your Honourshave listened with a great deal of patience to the: whole Of this Long and sad case, and I do not wish to prolong the agony any longer than I have to, but Your Honours have allowed a great deal of testimony to go'in with to opinions as to whether ithe Police were justified in firing fon these unfortunate victims, and gon have also allowed medical evidence to be given as to whether the shots were from the back or from the front. If your Honour had not allowed that to go in but had simply tried the technical charges before you, then it would merely have been a case of rioting and the publication of these banners fand T would have moved for missal of the case without going through all this testimony. In my humble opinion there is no ques tion whatever that the Police have failed t6 prove the charges against the students I represent. One or two Policemen have come forward and picked out 3 or 4 men and said they were people they had arrested or turned over to others, hut, against these individual accusations there is the unanimous denial of each and every witness for the defence, so that, upon the weight of evidence, I would ask your Honours to state that the preponderating weight of evidence is for the defence.
But I cannot conceive of your Honourshaving held this protracted trial, nor can I conceive, in the Chinese people being inter: ested in merely disposing of a number of charges of rioting against several students and other people. There are far larger issues facing this country at this time, and these issues have been partly threshed out in this Court, and T woul ask' the indulgence of the Court to} touch upon them in my 10 min-
As I have said, I have moved you to dismiss the charges against these students because the evidence is overwhelmingly in favour of the defence, so that I will say no more about that, but the larger issues which are facing the Chinese people at this time, and, I think, they interest the foreign community just as much as the Chinese people—ofthere larger irenes, I wilh only mention two.
The first is the vague notions fof equality. We are living in a different age to 1900 and the methods employed in the suppression of the Boxer rebellion are longer employed, and cannot be employed in this 20th century. We have progressed two decades since then and the Chinese people have advanced in general. intelligence. With that general.advance in intelligence, we have become more sensitive to outside influence, whether Bolshevik, economic or socialistic. They are susceptible to these influences: from abroad. Not leust_amongst these influences are the influences, of humanity, considerations of! humanity, notions and sentiments of patriotism. When I refer to notions of equality, I mean to say that people cannot he expected this age, to look without any question upon all manner of me qualities in their political and so-feal life wherever they may he.
There are certain privileges in this country enjoyed by forcigners which are not enjoyed by Chinese. I am not speaking of them in any spirit of anti-foreignism or criticism of the foreigners. I am simply stating a fact, and the Chinese people, as they grow in intelligence and advance in progress, economic as well as social and pol: tical, are not disposed to tolerate yern' when they see those inequalities, even if they could. So that out of the ignorance of the past, thelethargy of the immediate past and in this new century of the League of Nations and of new world forces, let loose by the Washington Conference and other world conferences, they are looking into the future with greater hope and with aspirations which are legitimate! td these people as well as to every people on earth. That larger issue] of equality, as applied to the local situation, is that they should be treated as men and not, thing lew than men. Ti intue which I should briefly refer [to is the demand and the desire fand the earest passion of justice which characterises the- Chinese people a, this articular hour in demanding this justice, they are not characterised by blocd-thirst, nor are they persecuting any Police Officer or anything of that kind. But they are looking for justice just the same, Judging thefsitnation by these two larger issues I will leave the matter in your Honours' hands, knowing that the public will judge by your Honours' just decision in this matter, and by statements which have already been issued. by responsible Chinese, [public men, that they are not antiforeign nor Bolshevik, but that they are wanting what I have tried to characterise as equality and justice, In this time, when the atmosphere is s0 changed with bitterness and animosity, and national prejudices, it would be well for me to read the concluding. portion of a statement issued by several Chinese Statesmen, because this statement. is concilitory in nature, form and substance, and T will conclude my remarks by reading the concluding portion of much of the welfare of the foreign communities in China, and the interests of foreign trade here, feeling of mutant understanding depend upon the existence of a
fand confidence, between the Chinese and foreigners in China, that, not on the high ground of just: ce, at least as a matter of sheer' expediency, it would be well for the foreign'nations or their agents in China, who still exercise special Tights of' a political character, nowhere exercised' by foreigners in Jother great countries, and who still enjoy extraordinary privileges nowhere enjoyed by foreigners in other civilized lands, to seck to understand the view-point of the Chinese people and at least in some measure to consult their interests in matters vitally affecting them, especially relating to questions arising in the foreign settlement where as a rule, they are not accorded the right to vote, which the foreign rate-payers enjoy, though they contribute thie main' portion of the Municipal revenue by paying the ball of the taxes, it is equally important, however, that no class of the Chinese people should seek to. antagonise the foreign residents in China or the countries they represent, merely because they still hold on to their special rights and §& privilege The great problem of treaty revision and re-adjustment of the basic relations between China and the foreign nations, can not be settled to the entisfaction ut both sides by coercion, antagonism, force or violence on either side. In the circumstances as they stand today, can be settled only by friendly consultation, sympathetic under standing and mutual conciliation, It is in that spirit of conciliation jand by attempting to understand the psychology of the Chinese people at this hour of (transition that you will be able to get out of the atmosphere of bitterness and arrive at a just conclusion in this cave, Mr. Maitland:—The charges are before the Court and certain of these men have been charged as ringleaders.—Whatever other puni-ment the Court may give these men, Task that the ring-Teaders shall be expelled from this Settlement. The Court has heard quite clear evidence of what they were doing and we know perfectly well thatthe students of Shanghai University all went out on the same afternoon, with cthers, to give [these lectures in the International Settlement, and it is undoubted that they must have hed n com The Court, her had _oonslesive ined arrangement together,
jetidence of what kind of literature is used in this university. I said jin my opening statement, that Bolshevism was behind all this, and I think I have proved that up to the hilt. At, the same time, the Court has copies of the pam-pilots which were distributed in janking the students, and of the tet jets which. were found, ip. the university so that Sent Shire doubt the students
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.