The Archive · 1912

Bitter Resentment

Although at present, so far as I am aware, the " Daily Telegraph" is the only important journal which has pronounced condemnation on Sir Sidney Lee, there is not the slightest doubt that the views it expresses this morning are very strongly and even bitterly entertained by many who are deeply concerned in some of the later political incidents with which Sir Sidney Leo has dealt. It may well be doubted, however, whether the main grounds on which the journal bases its condemnation are really those which weigh with them. The rule of the "Dictionary of National Biography" since its first volume appeared, now good many years ago, has been that the life of no living person shall appear in it. There has been no other limitation than that; and there must be scores of bio graphies which were published within a much shorter time after death than that of King Edward.

The question then aris is a British Sovereign so sacrosanct that an altogether different rule should be applied to him? King Edward was beyond all question s most popular and a most deservedly popular monarch; but it is surely an exaggeration to represent the nation as so weighed down with gloom under the shadow of his recent death that they cannot bear to read a word of criticism about him.

Kindly, Good-Hearted Man."

It in indeed evident, as the article proceeds, that the real ground of objection to the biography is to be found in its revelations contained in it, in regard to the part which Ki Edward played in the political crisis which was at its height at the time of his death and not the judgement passed upon his character. What is it" the "Telegraph" asks, "that before this biography appeared, we knew about King Edward? We bad learnt to love him for certain graciousness of manner, combined with a kindly dignity. We admired the easy tact and knowledge of the world which enabled him to establish happy relations, not only with those with whom he must personally have disagreed in this country, but with the statesmen of other lan'

Nor will the world s000 forget his momentous interviews Wit the Tsar of Russia, together with

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account