2. The defendant bank is a Chinese bank carrying on business at Kiangse Road, Shanghai.
3. November 16, 1911 Liu Yen-i, the then Taotai of Shanghai, by 8 despatch bearing such date, requested the Senior Consul to take charge of and administer the funds and securities belonging "to him in his office as Taotai, and transferred to the Senior Consul all such funds and securities, and the Fight to collect payment of and receive the same.
4. The defendant bank as bankers held at such time, and still hold the sum of Ts. 50,000 to the credit of the said Taotai and the right to receive the sum and the pass book for the sum have been assigned to the Senior Consul as stated above.
5. The Senior Consul has requested the defendant bank to pay to him the said sum of Tls. 80,000 but the defendant bank have objected to pay unless ordered to do s0 by this Court, The plaintiff therefore prays, that the defendant bank be ordered to pay such sum of Tls. 50,000 to the Senior Consul and pay interest due thereon.
No reply was fled by the defen-
Me Lis, Oppe_ appeared on be-
dants were represented by Mr. half of the plaintiff and the dete G. Mossop.
Mr. Oppe, addressing the Court, said that the case was of a similar character to that heard about two weeks ago by that Court. Therefore, it would not be necessary to repeat all the arguments then put forward. In this case the plaintiff claimed the payment of Tls. 50,000 in these circumstances. Before the the revolution broke out the Taotai had Tls. 50,000 on current account with the defendant bank, and this sum was transferred to the Senior Consul for the reason stated in the last case. The defendants admitted that they held this Tls. 50,000 on behalf of the Taotai, but before paying the money over to the Senior Consul they wished to have the authority and protection of the Court.
After desiing with the correspondence that passed between the parties, Mr. Oppe said that with the exception of the Bank of Communications, practically all the banks that held monies on behalf of the late Taotai had paid up either wholly or in part to the Senior Consul and arrangements were made, in the absence of proper authorities to take over the affairs of the Taotai. There were practical reasons why the money should be collected and used for the purpose was intended. In the circumstances he asked the Court to make an order for the money to be paid to the Senior Consul and also to give the defendants the protection they sought.
Mr. Mossop in reply said that the bank was only established last year and the aim of its establishment was to save a n the Shanghai market. At that time cash money in circulation was very scarce, ' and accordingly the Governor of Soochow instructed the Provincial Treasurer of Kiangsu Province to put Tls. 200,000 in the bank and he also instructed the Shanghai Taotai to pay in a similar sum, It was feared that if Tls. 200,000 were brought from Soochow it might affect the market there, and the result was that the Governor of Soochow asked the Shanghai Taotai to find the whole of the Tls. 400,000, it being understood that half of it was to be advanced on behalf of the Provineial Treasurer of Soochow and would afterwards be returned by him. When the Taotai received the instructions he the defendants a document of transfer entitling them to obtain the money, and in return he received a pass book which entitled him to four lakhs. The document of transfer was returned to the bank by theTaching Bank, but the pass book was never returned to them by the Taotai. After that the market got a bit of a rise and the Taching Bank ultimately gave the defendants one and a half lakhs.
About the same time the Bank of Communications gave half a lakh also and the two lakhs were entered to the credit of the Provincial Treasurer of Soochow. After that the Bank of Communications paid to Counsel's clients in instalments Tis.
50,000 and that was the sum now in dispute. It was not all paid in cash, Tls. 15,000 being represented by a Promissory note. The revolution then broke out and the defendants in the course of time received a despatch from the Commissioner of Finance of the Military Government. of Shanghai to pay over the two lakhs belonging to the Provincial Treasurer of Soochow and the money was paid.
At the hearing of the last case, proceeded Mr. Mossop, Counsel for the defendant gave the Court several reasons why the money should not be paid over to the Senior Consul. As the Court would remember those reasons, he (Mr. Mossop) did not purpose repeating any of them. His clients firmly believed that the day would come when the new government of China would call upon them to give an account of this money,
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.