The Archive · 1921

The Dutch Banks Case

Suly 2

Tre judgement delivered Supreme Court yesterday morning is in accordance with the general expectation. Most of us! have learnt something about the Gaming Act since the year 1910, some metely as spectators at the legal proceedings in which it has figured, others, perhaps, with that prudent instinct for a port in future possible storms which enables so many persons of questionable deserts to live on the fat of the land. But whether we have Jearnt little or much, it was difficult to imagine that institutions of the respectability and standing of the two Dutch banks concerned in this case would lend themselves to R gamble in margins, however glittering an appearance of wealth the other party might display. For, contrary to popular beliefs, there is never any real certainty of winning on a gamble.

The case was of extreme interest both because of its far-reaching possibilities, and because, as his Honour Judge Grain observed, it was the first of the kind recorded in the Supreme Court. Hence a certain difficulty in reaching a decision. On the other hand, it did not really matter whether the contract between banks and bankrupt was for the delivery of so much gold, so many apples or so many cargoes of spillikins. The point was whether the banks meant—in the light of subsequent circumstances we may add, "'if they could''—to get delivery of the commodity in question on the stipulated date, or merely to receive or pay the difference between its value then and at the date on which the contract had' had been made. The law, as ex: plained in his Honour's admi: ably clear judgement, is quite explicit on the point. For the Gaming ct to apply, there must be a definite understanding between the parties that the commodity sold is not to be delivered. In one case it is laid down that there must be two separate contracts, one of which would specify payment of margins only. Tu the present instance, not: only.was there no subsequent contract of this nature to supersede the original one, but the Dutch banks had satisfied themselves at the time of agreeing to buy the gold from the bankrupt that he was likely to be able to deliver; and as the date of delivery approached, they inquired of him personally whether he would be in a position to pay up, as otherwise they would have to buy against him. One curious feature in the hearing was that Mr. Toeg was not put into, the box, as there is reason to believe that the evidence he might have given of conversations between himself and the bank managers as to the bankrupt's financial expectations last August would have told materially in the banks' favour. However, they had no difficulty" in proving their own bond fides at least ad genuine traders, and may be congratulated on the moral victory of.clearing their good name, though of material fruits the bankrupt's estate does not promise them much enjoyment.

Nevertheless, without the faintest reflexion on the banks, and speaking quite generally, would, we think, have been by no means a bad thing for Shanghai as a whole if it had been legally possible to apply the Gaming Act. Of exchange transactions, which, morally if not in the eyes of the law, are nothing but sheer gambling, there are far too many and on too vast a. scale for the com-

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account