The written judgment wax shown to me yesterday morning. A Chi-meso judgment consists of three parts—Decision, Facts and Reasons, In any other country it would he assumed that something reasonable would be called for by this form that under the herding "facts would be stated what the Court has found to be the facts in the case, and that under the heading "rengons" would be set forth the arguments on which those findings based, The gift of this. judge ment which is very short Is as, follows:
Decision—Fourteonmanths im= prisonment and to pay $1,000 compensation to plainant, the truck 0 nelizently ax knock down the complainant and mitre. in Renson—The necused was so nee seligent in driving the telok that he caused serious injury to the complainant. This Lvoing negligence inthe performance of his secupation, comes under the second part of section (iii) of Article 301 of the Criminal Code.
Asked what he found to be the facts proving negligence ga Jude produce son from the scene of the accident, but which he has er theless inserted inthe written record of the evidence given in Court, and said that the fret for knocking down, ant then collided with, a wall instead of stopping hid jowed that the accused mnixt have Tle concedes, how. cas "probably some the part of the The Judge's Ignorance With all respect to the Iudge—he "understands nothing whatever about-motors an thole tnechanitm. "Un evidence ws called {rh esr tothe size ant weir the motor truck, "The only vent enncerning the speed Watt' six ini an hour. The nected, who nye he wa8 drivin
audition of the. brakes anid the distance within which it would. be Possible to stop the ruck when Travelling at various speeds has also not been considered, that selion body: must he severely and Ghat where street concerned the mere fact that ths] accused wae driving primi facie evidence wf his will, Moreover, exes such 2 these Where the is out to get all he possibly can from the accused, and the court records show that the difference between the way Police prosecutions and private prosecutions are dealt with in this court is remark-
Comparison of, Sentences Less than a month ago 1 had occasion to protest. when—as a result of a re-trial ordered by the Provincial Government—a sentence of ten years' imprisonment passed unpen a student found guilty of ug to extort $10,000 was to six months (one fifth of the term which can be imposed under the new Criminal Code). That wed to be educated, and— for a carefully thought out crime, which was linble to" culminate in violence,—six months' imprisonment insidered to be adequate punishment.
Here, however, is tunedueated coolie, who at the very worst has been careless, and the earned Judge considers that fourteen months! imprisonment (more than half the term which can be imposed under the new Criminal Code) plus $1,000 compensation is 1 very Tight sentence, To pat the ease in the most] favourable light possible—the guilt of the accused has proved. The Judge's judement is a frivolity and an sult to the intelligence of anybody who may have to read it, L cone sider this to. be a deliberate mis-comparison which have been Judge of this Court in eases in vol ing crimes of violence, the severity of the sentence passed in this ease, even if negligence had been proved, savours of nothing so much as >f reprisal against the aceustotally beneath the impartial judge.
Literary Amusements it is hoped to secure the partial administration of justice this Court, there are at least two pre-requisites. 'The first is that the public should be educated up to a point where justice and' the Jaw will no longer be looked upon fas the monopoly of those administering hem" The second Ie that to whom is entrusted the ministration of justice and the enforcement and interpretation of the Inw should be prevented from.
carding laws, ontinances and rales procedure, merely as the literary nmucement of their compilers, to which neither meaning nor im= portance need be attached practice. Till these innovations have been introduced, the Inws of ay, he—will re protest against the casual manner in which the ease against the cased as been conducted, ant against conviction and' the passed against him, all of I consider to he an atrocious ud deliberate injustice. accused should appeal, and.
the hoped that the learned the Court of Appeal witl vou to rescue this Court fron the unenviable reputation whic! some of the judges are earning for
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.