Owner Not Liable for Acts of Driver Under By-law: Decision by British Magistrate.
Can the holder of a motor car licence be held responsible for any contravention of the by-lays committed by any person in charge of the car? The point arose at H. M. Police Court last Friday during the hearing of a case before Mr. G. W. King in which C. P, Rakusen, of 42 Whangpoo Road, was summoned for improperly driving a motor car in Nanking Road.
{nspector Coghlan explained that, having been unable to discover who was driving the car at the time, the police had proceeded against the licencee of the car.
Mr. W. Wakeford Cox gave evidence that on the afternoon of the 4th instant he was driving a car in Nanking Road and was the last of four cars held up by the police constable on point duty at Chekiang Road corner. They had just received the signal to proceed and were crawling when car No. 1953 (defendant's car) passed them at a considerable rate of specd. Witness was unable to recognize the driver, but noted the number of the car and reported the matter to the police. This was not the first time defendant had been observed to commit a breach of the regulations.
Mr. F. B. Pitcairn, who was with the last witness, gave similar evidence.
Derexpant's Story.
Defendant pointed out that the summons did not describe the particular contravention complained of, and it was only now that he recalled the incident. He explained that the four cars mentioned were on the left of the traffic island and that he drove up on the right, there being a clear way on the tram lines, Just as he got level with the leading car of the four the police constable gave the signal to move on and he accordingly proceeds Tnspector Coghlan explained that repeated efforts had been made to obtain from defendant the name of the person who was driving the car at the time.
Defendant's answer to this was that the car was driven by various persons, including himself, on the day in question, and it would have been easier to discover who drove the car if the police had made their inquiry on the following day. He could produce a number of letters from the police in which the nature of the alleged offence was always stated.
Defendant added that, at the time he passed the four cars, they had actually begun to move in obedience to the police signal.
Tue JupGEMEsT.
His Worship. in giving his decision, discussed at some length the position of a licensee under by-law 34, saying it was the first occasion on which the point hed been before the court. The first of two points n prohibited without permission. to be considered. was, whether the wording of the by-law as it stood was sufficient to bring the licensee within its purview. The actual wording was that "the Council may impose such conditions," ete., and, therefore, it seemed to be in the minds of the framers that the bylaw would cover not only infringements of its terms, but of any condition of a licence issued under the by-law. This being so, the question arose: how far was a licensee liable for any condition of his license? Generally speaking, he could not be liable for everything—as for example, anything that might happen through. his chauffeur taking out his car on a joy ride: though if there were a condition that the licensee would be Jiable for negligence by the driver he would be liable in such a case. Obviously, this would throw much too heavy a responsibility upon the licensee. Condition 8 of the licence in his case stated that the licensee would be responsible for any damage caused by the negligence of the driver or other person in charge of the vehicle: but this condition, his worship pointed out, would be ultra vires, since in it an attempt was made to decide a point of law which should be the subject of a civil action, an action in which a jury would determine the facts and the judge would decide the law.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.