The Archive · 1925

Counsel and Witness

Too"

The Story of a Promissory Note The suit of the Citizens' 'Trust and Savings Bank of Chicago against Mr. Lansing W. Hoyt, of Mann & Hoyt, inc,, for payment on promissory note' for G.$2,127. Iheard by Judge M. D. Purdy in the U. S, Court On Friday last, presented the unusual spectacle of a lawyer conducting an examination of hi self as witness. Mr. W. Chalaire, (for plaintiff, put questions t> him:

If and answered them as a wit ess for his clients. Bir. Schuhl represented the defendant.

Mr. Ohalaire stated that although request for payment of this demand Promissory note dated December 27, 1923, had been made on June 19, 1925, the defendant hed failed and refused and still failed and fused to pay the note or any portion thereof.

Mr. Schuh! moved for a dismissal of the case, on the grounds that the plaintiff had failed to prove that ithe "note referred to was due. Judge Purdy, however, ruled that this was a matter of defence and the case proceeded.

"Mtr, Schuhl quoted from a con tract executed at the same time which provided for the payment of two notes by defendant to plaintiff la partial payments at such times as wore set forth in the contract A demand note of G.$2,127.78, covering fast interest due and attorney's fees was given by wit ness, to be surrendered to witness without further payment upon the completion ofthe content Defendant state! that pay monte bad been made ay provided with the exception that with regent to the payment of G.8750 due on january, 1925, he had during Deesmber, 1924, while in Chicago, taken up the matter of a compromise payrmiont in full with the President. of {he Corporation and that the president had agreed to let him know sehether We offer would be acca si J_was unable to learn Defendant way returning than, was agreed that the plaintiff should notify him in Shanghai through the Equitable Eastern Banking Corporation" during March, Ho had heard nothing from them until Mr. Chalaire demanded payment of this promissory note and informed hint that his offer had not been accepted. Witness then made another compromise offer for settlement. in furl, which was also not accepted, He then paid the G.8760 due and also the July payment. As the de-{lay was due to plaintiff's action and jas his payment, although deferred, had been accepted he felt that the contract had been complied with and that the promissory note, which was only due in case the terms of the contract were not met, was in no way payable, The case rested here and both counsel presented their arguments Mr. Chalaire agreed to present a brief giving the fal authorities on which he based

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account