The Archive · 1925

The New Music

A Musical Cninic's Houoay.—By Crest" Newman. (Cassel 125.

What should be the critic's sttitude to the "new" music? Should hho welcome it because it is "new" and endure humbly, the distressing, experiments of arrogant persons in tonality or polytonality or quarter-tones? If he expresses dislike for these unusual noises, is he not being the same kind of donkey about van Dicren as Artusi was about Monteverdi, or Sarti about Mozart, or Hanslick about Wagner?

Mr, Newman answers these ques-jons with characteristic thoroughness. He goes back to history and finds that "howlers" have usually been made by a negligible number of curities who have been concerned, ith points of musical wstheties, points of musical science; and that, in fact, there never was genuine greatness and originality who had to wait long for public recognition, The name of Wagner instantly caps to the mind; but was-not the execration of Wagner due to the "impossibility" of that very difficult an himself even more than to the difficulty of his music? The public that went to enjoy itself filled the theatres on Wagner nights, while: the pedants were still filling' paper.

can cite myself as a small example. I began opera-going as a writh in 1890—and a very' good ime it was to begin, To me, "Lohengrin" (then my. favourite) was an opera, as "The Huguenots" was an opera: only I thought "Lohengrin" much better. But there were people who still thought it a kand of monstrosity, and wrote very severely in the papers about the the scene between Ortrud and Telramund in Act. 1, a scene I specially enjoyed. Yet while few orities vented their print-disparagements, the gallery at Covent Garden ~was filled with people like myself, who drank it all with delight. Nor did Wagner Jack his defenders in the Press, Mr. Newman deals with "new-ress" in music, and shows that in music, as in everything else, we proceed on Bagehot's Principle of ive innovation" (I hail, a fellow-disciple of is, we take what we in digest, and reject what we can't, What is pecially remarkable lay new music is that it is really new. It is the first genuine revolution that has happened since the end of the 16th ce tury, when a few people, feeling that' the pure tone—the pure "in= strumentalism"—of vocal polyphony was leading nowhere, decided that they would go back to the Greek idea of mating music and poetry, What they produced was not the old classic drama, but the new Italian opera, together with music that had the spirit and manner of poetry. Our modern revolters want to get away from "literary" music back to music that is pure sound. that composers shout and What nobody seems to notice is

critics rave, the public (as usual) takes what it likes out of both kinds, The public simply does what Mr. Newman says the critic must try to da: it judges music, not by its novity or its antiquity, but simply by its immediate beauty, This is not Mr. Ernest Newmat best book, but it contains some of his best" work—indeed, it contains some of the best musical criticism written in our time—"Westminster Gazette."

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account