The Archive · 1929

The Mukden Executions

To the Editor of the jontit-Cuixa Datey News." imagine that many of your' readers" shared with me feeling of deep disappointment in reading your Mukden cortespondcent's description of Yang Vu-ting''s last birthday as published in your issue of the seventh of the execute of Yang Vu-ting and Chang Yin-huai gave one the impression that the tial and sent fence were nothing else than a cold-our help ax soon ax possible by sending us donations not earmarked for any special purpose but for needs of the Russian Relief from the Mukden authorit ed that there was a kind of trial, gave the names of the judges and made many assertions that the Association to enable us to tide over the months of February ard March especially, when the plight of the poor, badly fed, badly clothed and' two condemned men were plotting against the government. Of eve dence there was not a for Were documents found when the homes badly housed, is even more terrible St the accused were searched. and than during the warmer seasons, Gla these documents reveal that Thanks to Donors such treachery had occurred? If We trust that you, sir with find] "AY were not these documents quot-it possible to present in full the: ed? Were witnesses heard and those witnesses testify to the er attached Fist of contributions and finality of the accused? If s0, ay statement of disbursements referred why were the names of these wit to in this letter. We hope that the many i and gentlemen who nesses not given and their testi-so. generously contributed many set forth? articles of clothing will not take ex-Now comes your correspondent, ception that we have not printed with a tale of the birthday eelebratheir names but having already: tions of Yang Vu-ting's name day made so much claim on the space and his mother's 80th birthday, It of your valued paper, we do not. was the kind of festivity that any think that we can possibly ask you Chinese in the exalted position to print the names of about Sfty. of the dead general would have generous donors, held. The presents were, perhaps, We thank our friends and support a3 your correspondent, states, ex: ers for all that they have 0 readily travagantly valuable. "Yang Yu-Jdone in the past and hope that they ting," says your correspondent, as long as the situation of Russian emigrants is as critical as is "began to discuss with his guests whether it would be better to an-ounce himself as absolute dictator or to bargain with Nanking." This is hearsay only. If such speeches were made they should have been stifled to at the trial by those who had listened to them. I do not ay they did wot take place; I only point out that your correspondent' Statement is not evidence, Then we get this amazing sidelight on the method of the trial. "On the evening of January 9 a newly-organized committee sent Yang Yu~ ting an urgent summons. The future dictator found himself pushed into a dirty room and, when he began to protest and to scream. he was Knocked on the head and vold to be quiet." This sounds extremely like the record of a trial under the Russian Cheka, "A new= appointed committee!" Tt looks Unpleasantly like a packed jur He was pushed into a dirty room. Why? If two men, holding the highest positions in the government of Manchuria, were to be tried for their lives, surely there was a court. room or a'counell chamber available where a duly constituted court might sit to weigh judicially the grave charges about to be advance ed. "When he began to protest and to scream he was knocked on the head and told to be quiet." Your correspondent does not tell us what. else was in the "ditty room." Was file of soldiers drawn up there? Was the prisoner not entitled to protest that he should be given fair and open trial, "He was Knocked on the head!" In what part of the world, other than Soviet Russia, is a prisoner of state given such evidence of the kind of justice he may expect from his judges? And the accused were shot—in the Girty room?—during the night, Your correspondent sees nothing reprehensible in this which makes tone marvel at his. mentality.

Now I know nothing of Yang Yucting and Chang "Yin-huai cept that for some twenty years they were trusted advisers of Change Tso-lin. T seo nothing incredible in the accusation that they wore plot ting a rebellion. But the more overwhelming the evidence against them the more reason is that should be openly sot forth: Em-perers wore in the habit of occasion= ally calling a high mandarin to an audience and sending him from the foot of the throne to the execution but when such things hay a Republic one stands Tam, ote,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account