The Archive · 1925

ACTION FOR. REMOVAL OF} BUILDING

Story of Mutual Agreement to Surrender Land for Road Widening Before Judge M. D. Purdy at the U. 8. Court on Thareaday Mr, Koo! Lan-chow brought action against Mr. Edward Bell, of the Shanghai Building Ca., Fell. Inc., for the re-oval of a building which defendant thad caused to protrude om to private road, land for which hi Toutually' been surrendered by both parties and others. The petition tated that on October 27, 1907, an agreement was entered into by himself, the defendant and three others who were owners of lots contiguous to one another. Whereby the varlfous parties mutually agreed to surrender certain parts of their lands for the purpose of forming a roadway 30 feet wide. Te wae provided by the agreement that in the event of the roadway being: taken up oF otherwise disbursed by any of the signatorres {t should be reinstated at the expense of such.party. The road was constructed in accordance with the agreement,-the parties surrendering their respective strips of land. In breach of his agreement, plain tif alleged, defendant constructed upon the roadway a brick building foot long and 10 feet wide. BY reason of this, an obstruction was caused in the free use of the road by" plainti@ andthe other parties entitled to use the road. Defendant wan called upon to. remove the Building but had not done so and the damage he had suffered could not be compensated by an award of pecuniary damages. Defendant's Answer was that the building was not erected entirely upon the site of the voudway, but that it merely encroached to a relatively "smalt extent, The building was erected more than six years ago, prior to the filing of the complaint, with the Knowledge of and without' objection from plaintiff, until six years after its "erection, " "Defendant claimed that' plaintiff could amply be com: pensated, and that by reason of there facts and the plaintiff's know: ledge of the erection of the building and his failure to raise any objection, a8 well as his permission for the building to remain upon its site for six years, plaintiff was entitled to-an Injanetion but only such damages as could be proven.

Mr. M, B. Brown appeared for plaintiff; Mr. H. R. Snyder for defendant.

Plaintiff gave evidence bearing out his complaint and said that he had visited his land only three or four times a year during the lest six yours, bat did not notice the build-a there was a fence round his property and he always entered by the Dixwell Road entrance, Cross-examined, He said that he brought the action in accordance with the agreement entered into and that he had suffered damage because tenants were afraid and refused to ent his houses because of the build-mig defendant had erected. That was all the peconiery damage he had suffered, but if defendant erected a buildings others sise could do it amd the place would be of little value.

Defendant said that he had built the place intentionally after he had consulted the Tee Works' management, who: had no objection to its erection. As a metter of fact they gave him permission, but he did not consult plaintiff. The building hiad been there for six years and plaintiff or his son often visited their land but they raised no objection. If the building were demolished, it would cost a large sum of money.

In_cross-examination, defendant mentioned that plaintiff had a large furniture factory on hit tend, and about 100. men were employed here, He had given up 28 fect of his land for the road and plaintiff only two.

Mr. F. F. Ferris said that he visitedplaintift four years ago and the latter said that he was. generous in not making any complaint about the building.

Judgment was given for defendant. the French Mixed. Court_on Monday. Oto Christ, K- Hiller and a Chinese secretary to commander were fined $200, $100, and $50, or two months, tone month and. if days respective: 1y, for being concerned. in the ¥e-cent arms ease in the Concession.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account