tee Oct. 2.
ATTENTION has often been called to the fact that the ideas of justice are very different in jthe East from those held in the]
West. Some ancient Chinese! sage enunciated what have been called the "five cardinal virtues." These are Benevolence, Righteousness, Propriety, Wisdom and Truth. In this list it is to be noted that righteousness, which is rightness, another name for justice, occupies the second place. It is not the highest of the moral] attributes but is accorded the! position next to the highest. The Chinese philosophers were right! in this as they usually are on moral questions. Even the West, with its respect for legal justice, recognizes that the greatest of all virtues is charity. This was the argument that Portia used with Shylock. "For earthly power} doth then show ilkest heaven' when mercy tempers justice."
"droppeth as the gentle rain from heaven" whereas justice crashes like a thunderbolt from the sky. It is said that one told Confucius, "There is a very straight man in our place. When his father stole a sheep the son reported the matter." Confucius! replied, "We have a different idea of what is straight. A son con-coals his father's shortcoming and 'a father his son's. "Straightforardness is inherent in this."
In other words, there are cases, cher law supersedes and in these cases! rigid justice may be an injustice._
A few days ago a lady in this Settlement gave her table-boy notice that he would be dismissed at the end of the month. The! boy secured another position but! the new mistress said she would! call on his present mistress to! ask about his character. The boy told his mistress that the} lady would call upon her and explained that his wages in the! present situation were $15, but the "cumshas" which were forthcoming at the end of the month brought his income up to $20. "Now," he said, "when my new, mistress calls upon you, please tell her that my wages are $20] per month." His mistress demurred. She said "We foreigners do not tell lies like that. the lady does not ask me that will be all right, but if she must tell the exact truth boy is unable to see that this is! anything but pure spite., His mistress seems to him to be not! only dismissing him but is also, maliciously, preventing him from ig a better position. If his! mistress were to argue with him till Doomsday he would not change his mind. He is qui incapable of seeing why truth Gustice) should take precedence over kindness (benevolence).
Many stories are told to) illustrate how rigid justice works) out unjustly. One of these may) help us to see the other man's! point of view. One of the men who came to the front with Tseng.
Kuo-fan and Li Hung-chang during the Taiping rebellion! was Pao Chao. In the Biographical Dictionary, issued by the Commercial Press, he is said to have fought between six and seven hundred battles and beheaded more than 300,000] rebels. After his retirement he! was accustomed to go about! dressed "in mean garments, redressing injustices like a modern Don Quixote. Once he was sitting in an inn when a man came in hurriedly and demanded a bowl of vermicelli. The food not being forthcoming" immediately, the hungry man blustered and threatened the land-_ lady. Ultimately, he turned to go out, still pouring forth vituperations. At this moment the land-; lord came in and, hearing the altercation, concluded that the man was refusing to pay for the! vermicelli. Pao Chao jumped to the same conclusion and, revealing his identity, called upon the soldiers of the local garrison to behead this obstreperous fellow as a warning to others. After the execution it came out that the traveller had ordered vermicelli but hed not eaten it and so had died unjustly. Pao Chao now turned his anger on the innkeepers whose clamour had led him to kill an innocent man and ordered their execution to appease the manes of the unfortunate: customer. Thus three persons: died through an over-zealous attempt to attain to ideal justice.
We may agree that an uncompromising adherence to the letter of the law may not infrequently result in injustice and yet we are bound to maintain that, without justice, charity, mercy or whatever we may call the higher attribute, is impossible of attainment. Suppose a judge has a prisoner before him, The man proved guilty. The judge may, say, "You have been found guilty of a crime, but in consideration of your extreme youth and because this is your first offence you are discharged. Let this be 'a warning to you and do not be again found amongst lawbreakers." In such a case justice is! tempered with mercy but the supremacy of the law is also vindicated. If the offence were glored over and the culprit allowed to go free without the offence being brought home to him, he would reckon either that he was justly entitled to his) liberty or that he was such a clever scoundrel that he would always be able to break the law] with impunity. In either case] the result would be to confirm him in his evil ways and the reflex sentiment of gratitude, which merey should awaken in the heart of the recipient, would be entirely lacking. So we hold that for! kindness to be really kind tt must be firmly based on justice and the vindication of right.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.