The Archive · 1922

THE PRESS BY-LAW ONCE MORE

Mar. 28.

The Chinese printing organizations. are losing no time in working up their old agitation against the Press By-law, which for the seventh time of asking the Council will try to get passed at a special meeting of ratepayers next April 19. An enormous advertisement that they have published this week reveals the same strange inability to grasp the purpose of the by-law, the same complete misapprehension of its effects in operation China's door is not wide open Tana withal, though unconsciously, but it is ajar and it has only been turned thus far on its rusty hinges by the ceaseless pressure of the early traders against persistent opposition. Steamboats, railways, telegraphs, all the signs of progress to which Mr. Chao and orators of his type point so proudly, were they not all introduced by those pioneers and was not their introduction bitterly resented by Mr. Chao's forebears? When Mr. Chao says that China is in the position of the animal that provides the chief dish at the feast he is saying what his predecessors said when it was proposed to open certain ports to foreign trade. We will not repeat the malicious as well as absurd slanders that were propagated in the early days nor refer to their tragic consequences but it is disheartening to find a man in Mr. Chao's position echoing them in these modern days.

The unvarnished truth is that the western trader cannot succeed in business without benefiting the country he lives in. Wake a case in point. - There are a number of foreign merchants in Chefoo who have been agitate ing for years for the construction of a railway between that port and the main line traversing ihe province. Is that a dark scheme to injure China or would an admission of its justice. For, speaking of the practice in England, it says that, apart from the usual law regarding defamation, publication of printed matter is subject only to the restriction that the name of the printer and publisher must appear: on a specified part of the publication and. must also be registered at Somerset House. Now this and nothing more than this is precisely what the by-law proposed by the Council would require—with the sole exception that registration would be with the Council and not at Somerset House. In point of fact, the law in England is more severe than the by-law, inasmuch as the printer or publisher of any matter on.which his name does not appear is liable to be fined up to £5 a copy, which might easily mean a, fine of several thousand pounds instead of the lump sum of $800, which is the maximum fine specified in the by-law. And in general operation the law in England is very strict indeed. No printed matter, however trivial, is exempt from it.

All this was explained so fully to the Chinese a year ago, both in print and in many personal interviews, that it is extremely difficult to ascertain on what their fears are grounded. At one time they believed that. the by-

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account