The Archive · 1929

Application of the Acts

The argument that the gaming acts wore of a territorial appli tion, and were not intended to apply outside the actual realm—was advanced by Counsel for the defence in the case R. v. Harper and Hodds ("'North-China Herald," Iuly-Sept, 1912, p. 687). The Court hield that the gaming acts did apply With regard to the fourth point argued by the defence, viz. that if the Act.83 "Henry -'VIIT, 0.9 is applicable to China it is only applicable in cases where the'gaming house is occupied and run by per-ons subject to the jurisdiction of the Court, it appears to me that the fact that the person running' the common gaming-house and the premises on which the common kaming-house is run are not subjee: to the Jurisdiction of this Court do not make it lawful for British subjects to frequent and play at the common gaming-house, The only Aifference it appears. to me to make in the way in which the law can be enforced. IE the cor house had been run by Britis! jects on. premises owned and occupied by' British subjects, the Shanghdi Municipal Police would doubtless have applied to this Court for a warrant, on which the accused could have,'been arrested and Drought before the Court. The fact that the Police were unable to obtain years to me wake no difference ax far as the lawfulness of frequenting and pla ing at a common gaming house is concerned and if Tam satisfied by evidence other than that of arrest on the promises that the accused was present Tam bound to apply the law.

Plea in Mitigation Mr. MeDonald—Before you pass: sentence, or record ft, T hone you will permit _me, in fairness to the accused, 10 speak in mitigation of the sentence, as is usually done. To be bound over in the sum of $200, as may have been your intention, as fav as Lam aware is the maximum punishment ever inflicted for the offence with which my client is charged. A number of people may laugh at it, but at is a which remains for all cternunless obliterated by an pensive appeal. The charge is Solely under 38 Henry Vill and Strictly imited by that Act. Before Sen fefice the inaximom of any penalty, T hope you will forgive me it F put before you and repeat to a very' slight extent some of the considerations which are not frothy of your consideration, You twill reoreniber the scope and por "ipoaos of that Act. T dealt with in some detail on a former occasion

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account