Peking, July i4.
It is easy to see from the Chinese press, if one had no other sources of information, that the progress made by the strong popular reunion movement, has "prompted the Tuchuns everywhere to get together in a league and play against it the once popular provincial autonomy idea, each hoping through this to fight centralization and ensure his own job together with all the privileges that go with it. Tang Chi-yao, Lu Yung-hsiang, Li Hou-chi, Chang Tso-lin and many others have suddenly become advocates of what they do not in -the least understand and do not care to understand—a federalized China.
It is amusing to note from the telegrams constantly being circulate ed upon this subject that most of the high and mighty ones do not even distinguish between local self-government, which implies popular election of all magistrates, and provincial autonomy which, as a concept, may or may not imply democratic government. You can have provincial autonomy with hereditary princes ruling each province, and interpreted in this way it would probably make a strong appeal to the Tuchuns and no appeal at all to the people of the various provinces. But local self-government, involving popular election of all officials, from the Asven magistrates up to the provincial governors themselves, strikes a more deadly blow at Tuchun privileges than centralization does, and certainly is not what they want but what the people want.
Ir ry were UNDERSTOOD.
A clear conception of these terms, now so amusingly confused in the Tuchun hocus-poons which is being so widely circulated, would probabi ly put an immediate check to the movement, because the people do not want independent provinces ruled by independent Tuchuns without check from Peking, and the Tuchuns do not want local self-government with popular election of officials. When the people and officials both discover, therefore, that they are discussing radically different aspirations, the provincial autonomy slogan will be dropped og something too hot to hold. The officials will discover that the kind of provincial autonomy they wanted is anything but popular and they Will be afraid to use the slogan for fear that they be understood as advocating local self-government.
As a basis for the future reorganization of China the idea of a federated union of provinces is not a bad one because China's communications are poor and the arm the central republican government is not as long as the arm of the central imperial government was. But as a Tuchun's war cry it is now positively iniquitous being used to the iniquitous end of preserving the Tuchun system under another name, and it should therefore he discredited.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.