The Archive · 1922

Shanghai Custom and British Law

The Land Laws

The technicalities of the British land laws were the subject of amusing debate between his Honour Judge Peter Grain and counsel for Messrs. Abdoolally Ebrahim Ca., who in H.M. Supreme Court last Friday sued Dr. M. S. Mehta for Tls. 70 for rent due. Application was also made for an order of possession. Defendant (who was not legally represented) admitted that the rent was due, but maintained that he had taken the flat on g verbal agreement for a year. This the plaintiff denied.

His Lordship asked Mr. Kentwell (for plaintiff) if he wanted ejectment as well.

Counsel—If the defendant does not move out the Court will order ejectment. We claim for possession, which is ejectment.

His Lordship—Do you know that the land law is technical?

Counsel—In Shanghai it is simple.

His Lordship—Not in a British Court. We have to go by British land laws. They are very technical.

Mr. Kentiell then said it was the custom in Shanghai, to which his Lordship replied: It is not a question of custom in Shanghai. It is a question of British law. Shanghai custom thas nothing to do with The case was adjourned for two weeks.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account