Mr. Bos says that he and Rodfela Aiscussed the leticr of credit, that Rodfeld was told that it was their ble letter and that they never open irrevocable ones and that Roulfell y satisfied, Bos printed form of Jelter of credit used in another contract which states in. print, "although it is considered to be open may be cancelled by us. upon giving you notice." Box further states that he and Rodfeld had frequent further interviews and by reason of the phrase in documents of August 25 and August 26 "to Toad Iamber as goon as possible" and "early shipment" it was agreed between them that the letter of credit should expire on September 3 Rodfeld does account of the states that revocability was mot discussed at all; but he does say for an irvevoeable ter of credit.
He further states that his letter of September 4 to Muckenzie & Ca. asking that the "letter of credit, to extend till November 1920 was in consequence of hix having just heard thay it would Before the period, hut states hho does not know how or from whom hho heard it and can produce no letter or cable on-the subject and cannot state how he knew it was re-voeable. In fact that memories of all the partners, Rodfeld, Teplitsky and Ginsburg were extremely hazy fon a great number of important points in issue, and a seroot number answers were punctuated, do not remember." "Tt is pos.
do not, remember, not impossible". Teplitsky didn't even remember that he had signed the contract with Grodetsky, until it was pointed out to him that by the contract he had to sign, and then said, "I suppose T did sig In all their negotiations with Mackenzie & Ca. they spoke English, but in Court they spoke Russian and their evidence had to be interpreted throughout, The Date of Expiration There is nothing in the correspondence between the parties -to Show that they were unaware that this letter of credit was limited or that they had at any time objected to the limitation. "Inthe letter of tension by way of a favour -and again on October 22 Toplitsky Writes delivery of lumber has beea "delayed at Murashky—we thank you to have the said letter of credit prolonged until the Ist of December 1924", I feel therefore that must accept. Mr. Bos's "statement that the expiration of the letter of credit on September 30 was known to and arranged with Rodfeld.
On August 28 the Viadivostock: branch of the Hongkong & Shanghai Bank sent to Grodetsky the formal letter of credit, which is 3 printed document with' the words is considered to be open may be cancelled by us upon giving you notice," typed into the document.
Ginsburg, one of the _plaintidt partners, was at Vladivostok and it was he who entered into the agreement with Grodetsky to buy" the timber Ginsburg states that Grodetsky knew the letter of credit was revocable, Tt ix dificult to_ see how he could avoid doing so. That hho did not want to consent to the revocability, but did so in the end. So it is clear that at the time of the contract for purchasing the timber both parties, Ginsburg, one of the plaintiffs and Grodetsky, the seller of the timber, knew that the letter of credit was open until September 30, and that it was The agreement between Ginsbury and Grodetsky was duly entered into and signed by all the partners of Shanghai Lumber Ca, and Grodetsky" on September 9.
Why Ginsburg and Grodetsky.
ied_n contract which contained the phrase, "That the letter of credit issued in favour of Grodetsky. shall be irrevocable for the period of two months and after that may the cancelled" it is dimeult to say, Unless they" both relied upon Mackenzie & Ca, being prevailed upon te extend the eretit for that period,
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.