The Archive · 1930

From the Four Winds

VICEROY'S WARNING TO INDIANS Extremist Methods Will Only Damage the London Conference: — Reassurance to Business Men — Frost Ove Owx Conaesroxexr

Calcutta, Jan. 31.

'A warning to the advocates of civil disobedience, further light on. the functions of" the Round Table Conference to be held in London and an appeal to "all those who have the well-being. of India: at heart" formed the basis of the Viceroy's speech to the Assembly last week, points of Lord Irwin's fo, Guide Pecianent, and would woe bet accepted unchanged ty Pa weld. to. fashion' a Constit

'No' date had been fixed, but he would by Assembly"

Tenders of political taougi government would. discharge full its "renponsitlity foe jenanee "of authority Uunliwful methods were resorted to.

The Viceroy concluded with a striking appeal to "those who will represent India at the conference to utilize wisely the interval befor it is held to train the ears of the countrymen. in the call, to unity."

The address which the Viceroy delivered to the Legislative Assembly was in the nature of an amplification of the famous Statement, published in the form of an Extra" ordinary Gazette after Lord Irwin velumed from England.

roy has, of cours dressed the Assembly on many' pre~ vious occasions, but rarely in circumstances of such interest as at present. These circumstances made Lord Irwin's address to the Assembly therefore, of exceptional. importance; nor has the Viceroy disappointed his audience. Happily further Statement was deemed necessary, but what his Excellency said can definitely be reassuring, Points concerning which there has been furious controversy for nearly three months wore elucidated and defined; more over in addressing the Assembly Lord Twin gave a sharp: warning: to the Extremists which, of cour: could not find a place in the Star ment of November 1, In his original Statement Lord Inwin laid down the goal for India.

state the goal does not, how-over, mean that the' goal has been automatically and almost instanttaneously reached. No one but, the Genus Indian politician would have made such an assumption, nor has any footballer ever played football in such a fashion, The goal still remains, the Statement stands; the problem remains. Nor is the Lon-Conference being summoned to whicn any particular brand of Constitution through the simple process of counting Extremist head The supreme duty of Great: Britain and Parliament still re-amains; but the Conference will sit, after the fullest. preliminary con: sideration has been given to the report of the Statutory Commission, to offer guidance to His Majesty's Government in Sraming the next. stage in, the Constitution. Mr. Gandhi and his friends had the effrontery to demand that the Conference should be packed with Con-ares nominees, Congress being the The Viceroy in dignified language has once for all put. the any such absurd proposition that the destiny of the Conference will ibe decided by the counting of heads the exorcise, of personalities.

intrinsic soundness of any Particular proposals and the manner in which argument is presented will be more important factors in the Conference than the exact numerical representation enjoyed by any of the different sections of opinion that, will participate in the proceedings."

The same thing has been said by My. Wedgwood Benn over and over again, Indians must enter the Conference as far as possible united; whatever they can prove by. argument, will) be. fairly and sympathetically considered by the Cabinet, not at a time when minds have been made up but when everything is ope Tt is, however, no good to. under rate the diffeulties in the way. They are, as Lord Irwin, told the Assembly, "real and their existence cannot be disputed." At Bombay a few days ago the Viceroy spoke in eneral terms of problems presented by minorities; at Baroda and again in speaking to the Assembly' he voterred to the position of the Indian. States. These problems, to say nothing of the immense British and Imperial interests involved, will not be solved through slavish adference to copy-book maxims, The Congress may decree the celebration of Independence Day, but the Princes and the Moslem contemptuously decline to have anyig to-do with it, Argument and agreement is the only slogan that stands the slightest chance of carrying weight with the British public.

'A. mast damning impression has [een created by the spectacle [disunion created by the Report and the proceedings of the Indian Central Committee; by the attempt mortier the Viceroy; and by the Congress campaign, in reply to the Dritish Government's generous gesture, demanding Independence.

the next two years produce no hetter fruit, India's journey towards Dominion Status will resemble that of a traveller who, desiring to reach the moon, charters a bullock cart.

To those who think, perhaps not without some justification, that the British Government pay attention only to the threat of force or violence and the expression of ex-policies, the Viceroy uttered warning, There can be no composition or truce with those who violence whether mob or of individuals as the speediest solution of political problems,"

Sedition-mongers andthe advocates of disobedience and separation from the Empire are told frankly that the Government will discharge to the fell their responsibility for the effective maintenance of the laws, and for the preserve: tion of peace and order. Sedition, in short,' is sedition, Should any attempt be made actually to carry cut the Congress campaign, Europeans in this country trust that the fact will be recognized without motions such as in the past few months seem occasionally. to have inspired Government policy.

Does it only mean that, despairing of do ation over sober minds, it (the Congress) hopes to capture the tion of the unbalanced by a display of stage lightning and tin pot thunder?

Sit Malcolm Bailey, Governor of the United Provinces, made this reflection in the course of a speech at the annual dinner of the Upper India Chamber of Commerce at Cawnpore. He left it to his audience, which was composed of European business men, to read the riddle of the drama of the Lahore Congress but he warned the bazers of India against supplying the funds, as was done in the non-com operating years. "The account books of th8 mercantile community must show clearly enough the effects of that movement on the trade of those years.'

The supporters of the policy of the All-India Congress Committee, said Sir Malcolm, "possessed a state of mind standing somewhere tween the criminal and the insane"

—and..., only a Bedlamite or a Bolshevik: could seriously propose to shake the whole foundations of credit in India by talking of the repudiation of debts.

There were those, said the Governor who demanded independence of the British Empire and asserted that they intended to secure it by means which they did not pretend to be constitutional, which, indeed, many of them did not, attempt to deny would involve Iaylessness and violence.

Tndeed, the Governer proceeded, one wondered if one ought not in all charity to doubt whether this programme did actually represent the veal intention or the considered conviction of many who had recently given it their supfiort, "You must si ready have asked yourselves whether there must not have been some temporary aberration which could induce any Indian other than

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account