The Archive · 1920

THE LAW'S DELAYS IN CHINA

From " Correspondent, Peking, Dec. 30.

It is unfortunate for China that, at a time when she is anxious to prove to the world that a real effort is being made to bring the administration of justice in this country into accord with the more humane and enlightened ideas of Western nations, there should occur undue delays in the reformed judicial procedure already in operation.

The Singer Sewing Machine Company is a victim of this tardy justice as shown in the following facts: On January 11, 1918, the Company filed with the' magistrate of Wusih district, through the office of the Special Commissioner for Foreign Affairs at Shanghai, a suit against the Chung Hsing Shop and_others. Nine months later, on September 7, the Wusih magistrate gave judgement for the plain. tiff company for the full amount claimed. On January 13, 1919, as the judgement had not' been' enforced, the American Consulate-General in Shanghai wrote to the Special Commissioner for Foreign Affairs at Shanghai, asking for the enforcement of the judgement. The Commissioner replied that the records of the case had been sent by the magistrate's court at Wusih to the procurator of Kiangsu. Repeated requests by the Consulate-General for the return of the records to the magistrate's court proved fruitless.

Five months thereafter, on May 96, 1919, the higher court at Kiangsu informed the magistrate at Wusih ar the case bed been appealed to the supreme court an that the records had been forwarded to that court.

On September 23 the Ministry for Foreign Affairs was asked by the American Legation, in accordance with the law of China and the treaties between China and Foreign Powers, that the records which had been irregularly sent to the procurator's court and thence to the Supreme Court be returned to the magistrate's court at Wusih. The Legation pointed out that the Ministry for Foreign Affairs had itself declared that the only appeal from a decision of the Mixed Court, in which a foreigner was plaintiff and Chinese defendant was to the Special Commissioner for Foreign Affairs. In spite of the evident violation of the Chinese regulations. themselves, and additionally in spite of the fact that the judgement had even then been irregularly maintained by the procurator's court and the Supreme Court, the defendant was able to secure a mandamus calling for a review of the case and the procurator's court again took it up, and it is still in the hands of the procurator's court.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account