The Archive · 1920

P. Wilkinson, Crown Advocate

attended on behalf of the Registrar of Companies.

Mr. Levineon read an affidavit made by Capt. J. E. Inch since the last hearing, in which he stated that in addition to being managing director of the company he also un der took the duties of secretary. Deponent itemized the allotments of shares in the filing of returns of which he said the company had defaulted. The duty to file these devolved upon him as secretary ani failure to do so was entirely due to inadvertence and no other cause. He had never acted as the secretary of a company before ani was ignorant of the appropria' provision of the China (Companies: Order in Council, otherwise he would have complied with it.

Particulars with respect to the six paragraphs of the motion were attached to the affidavit and wit regard to the last. Capt. Inch deposed that he was ignorant of the provisions of the ordinances relating thereto and he left all procedure concerning such documents} in the hands of the other party concerned. Deponent went on to say that he was aware that certain instances of failure on the part of certain companies to comply with Hongkong Ordinances and Orders in Council relating to China com. panies had been raised in that, Court, but he had felt no anxiety as regarded the particulars cou-cerning his own company as_ they had retained a lawyer who. advised them on all matters pertaining to the company.

Considerable discussion then. followed relative to his Lordship's power to grant relief from certain. of the penalties or to inflict them, in the course of which his Lordship. pointed out that the most serious. matter was the failure to register: the charge over the assets of the company given in favour of the International Banking Corporation and said that if the document were registered now,.it would be without. prejudice to the rights of anybody wko had become creditors during the period between the drawing up.

the document and its registra-ion.

Mr. Levinson said that the mortgage would be re drawn, re executed, and re-registered.

Mr. Wilkinson in the course of his argument, informed his Lordshi> that there were still firms who were offending in a like manner to the applicants.

His Lordship:—All I can say that I hope the registrar will take proceedings against them. It is perfectly necessary for companies to find out what it is necessary to safeguard themselves against. 13. is not often that I refer to text books, but as a matter of fact there was one published by the Tientsin Press on the Companies Ordinances and Orders in Council which gives in simple form all the penalties to which companies are liable. It is: obtainable and I should have thought that every secretary and manager of British companies here ought to have had something oh that sort.

_His Lordship, in giving his de cision, remarked that as far as 4o. could' seo the company had re~ gistered very little with the gistrar of Companies since their incorporation in 1918. It was, in his opinion, the worst company application that they had had before. the Court up to date and it was admitted on the affidavits that the company was aware of the need of complying with the requirements. of the company legislation very cer. tainly from July or August of last year. It was quite easy for companies to get information in a printed form, information of what. were the penalties which might 5a incurred if they did not do their duty in compliance with the law and all managers -of companies ought to take steps to acquaint themselves with what their duties were. Dealing with the several ap-Plications in the motion, his Lordship pointed out that with regard to the first, the certificate of incorporation had been issued and as that was taken as proof that all requirements prior to that issue had been met, he would make no order upon that application. With regard to the list of directors, his Lordship said it was the duty of the Registrar to accept it when it was sent to him, though that did not prevent him' going for such penalties as had been incurred. In this connexion he was unaware that the Court had power to give Telief against penalties unless ex-

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account