The Archive · 1920

Renting a Flat

At H. M, Police Court on Monday Mr. G. W. King, Magistrate, was occupied the whole day in hear: ing a case in which Mrs, Mathilde Mitzkievitch summoned J. 8, Abraham for unlawful ejection from a flat at No. 4 Park Lane. The complainant is the wife of a former Judge of the Court at Irkutsk, now residing with his family in Shanghai.

The prosecution was brought under a little known statute of Richard Mr. de Ruffé appeared for the complainant, and Mr. Levinson for the defendant.

Briefly, the circumstances were that on leaving Shanghai, Mr. Abraham sub-let the flat to a Mrs. Fels, with authority to sub-let. On his return, he found the complainant and her family in possession and took steps to have them ejected. Complainant stated—that February 3 she arranged with Mrs. Fels to rent the flat for two months, at a rental of $102 per month. She paid the first month's rent in advance, and took possession on the sth of that month. She. clearly understood that the letting was for two months. On March 8 several men, complainant said there were seven, entered the house, and went into the room where complainant and her niece were in bed. They ordered the family to leave. Complainant put on her coat and ran into the street for protection, and went to the police station with her husband, the men meanwhile packing up the furniture and putting it outside the house on a verandah. Complainant admitted that no "violence" was used.

Several witnesses were called. and the Court adjourned.

Trespassens Witt po PRosect'

The case for the prosecution having been concluded, Mr. Ievinson submitted that the prosecution had inside out no case which the prosecution need be called upon to answer The complainants were not: tenants of the house at all. If they had been tenants there might have been some ground, but they were in fact merely trespasse?s and nothing else. When Mr. Abraham came back from India he had no knowledge that complainants were in the house, He gave no authority for their being there, and had never been informed that they were there. When ho came back he found some interlopers, trespassers in the house, and knew nothing where they came from. Counsel defined a trespasser as being one who was in the position of " squatter. In this case, the complainants had no colour of right as far as the landlord was concerned. In such circumstances, there was no need for the landlord to go to law in the His Worship—Why did he go to the Mixed Court?

Mr. Levinson—From an excess of caution. It shows that he was try-

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account