The Archive · 1920

Shell Shock and the Unconscious Mind

"Shell shock and the unconscious mind" was the subject of an address by Dr. Millais Culpin, 2.B., F.R.C-S- at a meeting of the Portsmouth Brotherhood in the Wesley Church, Arundel Street, Landport, in the early part of the present year, when he gave most interesting particulars as to the causes and cure of this distressing malady.

Dr. Culpin opened his address by mentioning the symptoms of shell shock, and pointing out that they were not of recent origin, but that similar symptoms prevailed in civil life, while he recorded an instance of what was really a similar case to shell shock which occurred in the Greek wars of 400 B.C. At first the condition was thought to be due to bleeding in the brain, but that theory had been dropped and it was now realized that shell shock was purely a mental condition. There was a continuous stream of thought in a man, continued the doctor, which was called the "stream of consciousness." A man usually thought that his whole existence was confined within this "stream of consciousness," but it was not So as there was a "deep sea of unconsciousness" or a, sub-conscious mind, beneath it, in which were inborn many things which affected a man's life and condition. These included his instincts, which did not come within his "stream of consciousness." They belonged to the unconscious mind, in which, too, was everything a man remembered and also everything ho had forgotten.

Conversation tHe Cure.

Returning to shell shock, the lecturer explained that one of the most prevalent symptoms of it was fear, but the patient did not know of what he was afraid- Some men were afraid to be in a crowd, some to be in darkness, and there were other trifling things of which they were afraid. One case cited by the lecturer was that in which a man was afraid of the buzz of a fly (it subsequently transpired that it was to him the drone of a German aeroplane). It had been found to be almost impossible to get men suffering from shell shock to talk about their experiences, or what they had gone through. They could not do so. It upset them to talk about it, but it was good for such men to do so. It was the duty of the physician to find out from a shell shocked patient, what he did know, and what had been the experiences that led to his condition; to bring them back to his memory, and induce him to face his trouble. It would be a mental conflict for him to do so, but in that conflict lay the man's cure. What had really occurred had been that he had pushed his fear, or some terrible experience, down into his subconsciousness, and there it had remained until some special circumstance, such as the explosion of a shell, or other violent explosion, had acted like the last straw" and he became unconscious. On his return to consciousness he

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account