The Archive · 1920

Japan in Siberia

NOTES & COMMENTS

The long statement from Tokio justifying the Japanese action at Vladivostok seems to come just a little under the familiar reprobation of Queen Gertrude: "The lady doth protest too much." We do not mean to imply the slightest doubt of the technical accuracy of the statement that the Russians began the fight. Against this, it is impos. sible to ignore the fact, attested by credible witnesses, that Japanese soldiers have, individually, behaved towards Russians in a manner hard to endure. Complaints of this kind have been heard since the beginning of the Allied intervention in Siberia and they cannot be left out of account in reckoning up the responsibility for the recent clash. On the other hand, it is difficult, seeing how matters stand in Siberia, to blame Japan for taking control at Vladivostok. The state of the country, as shown by Mr. Robert Wilton in the article we published on Tuesday, is one of absolute anarchy; and. in a larger sense than that in which the Tokio statement uses the words, Japan might plead that it was a Vital matter of self-defence for her to control the exits through which revolutionary infeetion might pass into her own borders. Her action at Harbin, where Japanese guards are—sai: to have occupied most of the strateale points, is less defensible. North Manchuria is Chinese territory and the record of General Pao Kuei-ching's Chinese guards at Harbin suggests that they are perfectly able to do the necessary work.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account