The Archive · 1920

By Dr. Arthur Smith

On the historic 4th of August Donald Hankey was in the country near Portsmouth. On the 7th he offered himself as a recruit for Kitchener's 100,000. The day after he enlisted (at the age of 30) he was made a corporal, and before the week was out he received the sergeant's stripes. On account of the great dearth of officers and by the advice of his brother he applied for a commission, which he afterward tried to resign from a feeling that he was not fitted to command, but the request was denied. ae, His experiences, after joining the army, were not unlike those of thousands of others, but he was exceptionally fitted to record them. He had studied hard at Oxford and had broken off to become a subaltern in Mauritius, which he left under medical orders. After his resignation he drifted about in many travels, going to Australia in the steerage, with a view to facing for himself the hard realities of life unhampered money or position. Here he had many and deep thoughts which found earnest expression in his correspondence. Just as the war began he had completed and was publishing a book called "The Lord of All Good Life; A Study of the Greatness of Jesus, and the Weakness of the Church," which was welcomed by some, and resented and criticized by others. As a soldier his mind was in a receptive state, and his pen was ready for use. During his first year of service he saw much that stirred the depths of his being. A fortunate but rather fortuitous introduction to Mr. John Strachey, owner and editor of the "Spectator," afforded the needed stimulus to set down in writing his burning thoughts, and to record in a quite impersonal way his own observations and his interpretation of them.

Tue InarticuraTe.

Thus he voiced the feelings of great rumpers whom he aptly termed the Inarticulate." The story of the terrible charge in which he received the wound from which he was long in recovering was told in an article in the "Spectator" of December 11, 1915, entitled "The Honour of the Brigade." Most of his chapters were either realistic descriptions of actual events, or studies of Kitchener's Army as 'a union of the classes in a common aim in life. "All Classes Were at One" described the crowds who enlisted at the beginning of the war, and what a plunge it was for the "plack-coated" classes. It was a unification of the classes in a common life and work, and not simply by a wave of sentiment. "The Equality of the Classes"

Edward Miller, aca. New York: class. "The Super-Class" describes the officers, and how the traditional view of discipline did not altogether succeed in this citizen army. "Men Wanted" describes how war completed the adjustment, how the good meu, both officers and N.C.0.'s, came to the fore simply through the fact that they were always on the spot in the moment of crisis while the rotters were in their dug-outs: and how we learned to see men as God sees them, and love them for the greatness of their hearts and their unselfishness, quite irrespective of their accents and their manners. "What of the Future?" asks whether we are going to drift back into the old artificial grooves after the war or whether the classes will have a wider outlook, a juster idea of whom to trust as leaders, a more unselfish and communal spirit in polities.

A Reay Iyrerpreration.

Of "The Religion of the Inarticulate" Mr. Strachey wrote to him: "I think you have hit me between wind and water as Burke says: It was a real piece of interpretation. If the theologians were as frank as the philosophers we ought to see the Archbishops of York and Canterbury writing to the "Spectator," as did Dr. Crozier, that you had said what they had been trying to say all their lives."" The book combining these and other papers (as everyone nex knows) was called: "A Student in Arms," although with much hesitation lest it should suggest Baby in Arms." It at once caught the eye of a public thirsting for realities. Tt had an immense vogue in England and down to the current year over 200,000 copies are said to have been sold in America.

Such phenomenal literary success naturally excited curiosity as to the intellectual and moral background of the writer. To satisfy this legitimate demand this book of intimate letters is published. They cover all the years of his life from the age of 0 to his death in 1916, and are rightly regarded as refreshing, living, and quickening. There are letters to his sister Hilda, and to many of his family, to college and school friends, to boys in the Bermondsey Mission where he worked so long, to army friends, to rectors, "bums" and bishops. Of the Ihtter he says, "Least of all am I bitter against Bishops and the clergy as individuals. It is because I have stood very near, and looked very hard and with keen personal. interest into their lives that I have come to the conclusion that they are the helpless victims of a wrong and anomalous state of affairs. The training given to them, and the machinery at their disposal, and the expectations of the Laity, conspire to make it almost impossible for them to do their job well." the best clergymen will say—generally with hesitation and regret—'If you can remain a layman, do. 1 believe that you will find better opportunities of service.' " Donald Hankey hated war, but he hated evil more. He was sure that the Church needed reconstruction. "As regards the church, one often despairs, and yet it still seems to me to be the organization out of which the church of the future must be born. But of course if I had my way the church would make very startling alterations in its composition and everything else-What I want is to dethrone the rulers of it, and flood out the pewholders with new blood, of the sort which gets the door slammed in its face at present."

And as to war: "Suppose the Good Samaritan had come up while his neighbour was being kicked about by the robbers, his position would have been very unpleasant if, with every good instinct urging him to go to the rescue, his religion had compelled him to stand by and be knocked about himself! And if the robbers had chosen to ignore his presence, he would have felt an awful worm."

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account