The Archive · 1920

U. S. Court for China

Case of Wrongful Dismissal In the United States Court for China on Tuesday, the Hon. C. 8. Lobingier, judge, delivered judgement in the case in which Mr, A. Tilton Steele sued the American Trading Ca. to recover damages for breach of contract to employ him in Shanghai as their chief accountant.

Mr. S. Fessenden appeared for the plaintiff and Mr. R. 8. Haskell for the defendants.

From the evidence it appeared that Mr. Tilton Steele was engaged on May 27, 1918, by the defendant company in San Francisco to proceed to Shanghai where he would be their chief accountant at a remuneration which would not be less than Gold $10,000 for the three years for which the agreement was to run, the undertakings as set out in a letter signed by the vice-president of the American Trading Ca. (Pacific Coast) to be dependent upon the plaintiff doing his work in an "efficient and satisfactory way." The plaintiff set sail from Seattle to take up his euiployment in Shanghai, but en route received a wireless message from the defendant's vice-president at Yokohama asking him to be prepared to leave the shin at Yokohama as he might be required in the Tokio office for some months before. going on to Shanghai. He did in fact work there until May 3, 1919. Op August 27, 1918, confirming his temporary appointment in the Tokio office, and on March 19, 1919, he received a further letter stating that the defendants had received word from Shanghai to the effect that that office having made satisfactory arrangements with their accountant there, ko, plaintiff, would not now be required to go to Shanghai, and further that upon the return of the gentleman to Tokio, for whom the plaintiff was deputizing, his ser-there. Defendant subsequently viees would no longer be required

came to Shanghai and offered by telephone to carry out his contract, but was told by the defendants' agent not to come.

For the defence it was pleaded that the plaintiff was engaged by the American Trading Ca. (Pacific Coast) a distinct corporation from the defendants; that plaintiff's work in Tokio was not done in an efficient and satisfactory way; and that as the result of an arbitration agreed upon between the parties and actually carried out, the plaintiff was debarred from proceedings in that Court.

In his judgement, his Honour reviewed the facts at'some length and held that it had not been proved that the plaintiff failed to do his work in an efficient and satisfactory way, or that the defendants sought to terminate the original contract on that ground, or that it was justified in so terminating the contract. It followed that the contract was wrongfully terminated.

Dealing with the point that plaintiff was barred in the action by the award given in the arbitration, his Honour upheld the plaintifis contention that the same was void, of no effect, and not binding upon him, and in the event found for the plaintiff for the sum of Gold $7,500, less $50 Mex. which the plaintiff {admitted having earned in the meantime, together with costs, Yoxoxasa now has a school of languages for Japanese young men, started with the idea of promoting the development of foreign trade. The school was officially opened in Honmoku last week Modern languages will be made a special study, although allied subjects are included in the curriculum. The popularity of the project is assured by the large opening class which numbered 180 pupils

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account