The Archive · 1923

DEFENDANTS' POSITION REASONABLE

The defendants maintain that it is essential to them in coming to an agreement to insure that in the event of a fire they shall have reliable information as to the. values of the goods destroyed or damaged, and what better evidence could they have than the ordinary working books of the firm.

If the books are kept in the same building with the goods insured, there is strong probability that the books will also be destroyed.

Therefore they make this stipulation in order that it might be certain as far as certainty can be attained to have the books to refer to for purpose of ascertaining the goods destroyed or damaged in case of fire in the place where the goods were stored. I have seen the plaintiff Mr, A. Nastasheffsky in "the witness box, and have heard him give his evidence, and I feel assured that he is not the type of in. dividual to sign amy document without thoroughly understanding the full meaning of it. Nor do I place any reliance on the statements said to have been made by Tetzner, the defendants' agent, because he has not been called although there were at least two occasions on which his evidence could have been taken de bene esse. Moreover, he had hada disagreement with his employers, the defendants, and the probabilities are that if he was in a position to give evidence adverse to the defendants ho would not have been disinclined to do so.

Nor do I think that the payments made on account of the fire on the premises in which some goods were damaged and some destroyed on March 27, 1921, affect the matter. It is suggested by the plaintiffs that this payment acts as a waiver of the stipulation to keep the books separate from the insured goods. The defendants state that when that payment was made there was no question of consulting the books; the damaged goods and the reinaing of the destroyed. goods were in existence and the amount of damage was assessed on the goods and their remains which were then-in cxistence.

I see no reasons on the facts of this case to come to the conclusion that because on the previous occasions the defendants for some practical cause, or even on the. ground of generosity, did not en. force this stipulation, that they are thereby estopped from enforcing it on the present occasion. Nor do consider the fact that the defendants offered to settle the matter for a certain sum without going into Covrt affects their right to enforce the stipulation.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account