The Archive · 1923

THE NORTH-CHINA

Elmont. Under the law of the District of Columbia and the Territory of Alaska, said Mr. Faison, the wife had a separate estate, but was not liable for debts contracted by her husband. In this jurisdiction the old common law was applicable, that a wife could not contract a debt, and he had not -found any ruling under this law making a wife responsible for necessaries for which her husband was responsible under the common law.

Mr. Maitland objected that Mrs. Elmont had received this service and that her husband's agreement to pay only made him jointly liable. If a wife with a separate estate was not responsible for goods which she had ordered then nothing could prevent a husband from placing all his goods in his wife's estate and having her incur all debts.

Mr. Faison remarked that such was the ruling in many cases, but was not the law in this jurisdiction and liability would have to be based upon a statute, otherwise the common law would hold. The defendants had no disposition to evade the law, but when they were struggling to make a living and the only proper Elmont had was in the household effects which enabled them to earn a livelihood, it was necessary to take advantage of every protection afforded them by the law, and under the circumstances to claim her full rights to prevent herself from being deprived of a home.

Mr. Maitland suggested that if the principle advanced by the defence were to prevail, gross frauds would result.

After hearing further argument, his Honour reserved his decision.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account