June 3.
Tne apology for the continued recognition of what diplomats ike to call the Government at Peking is made on the basis of two arguments. First, the diplomats say, if the Powers withdraw, recognition of Peking, the con~ tinuity of the treaties will be broken and the treaties will thus cease to be effective; secondly, that foreigners and foreign property throughout China will be without protection. As regards the first contention, one can only point to the fact that all the provisions of the treaties are now regionally enforced, or not enforced, by the local feudal lords without the slightest regard to the orders and instructions of the Waichiaopu. Last winter, while the Tariff Conference was in session, while the Government Peking was _negotiating treaties, the feudal military authority in the city of Peking imposed an illegal tax on foreign goods, in contravention to all the treaties. The Powers concerned protested; the Ministry of Foreign Affairs made the usual promises of redress. The illegal tax still stands and is still collected.
The thing called a Government in Peking is not even able to enforce the treaty provisions within the walls of its own city. Beyond those walls, it does not even make an attempt to enforce treaty provisions, The continuity of the treaties can just as easily be preserved, by regional agreements with the rulers of the various new kingdoms, whose control is effective, og with a historical seat of Government which has lost its power and influence. If the Powers arrange with the actual governors of the larger political spheres to continue international relations on the basis of the existing treaties, there will be a more certain enforcement of the Areaty provisions than at present. As @ matter of actual fact, the continuity, of, the. treaties is} maintained by Sun Chuan-fang in the provinees he governs; in Manchuria, by Chang Tso-lin; in Yunnan, by Tang Chi-yao and everywhere else by the ruling, dominant, powerful feudal lord. When a place like Canton presumes to break the treaties, a3 has been done there for more than a year, the Powers are helpless to make the treaties continuous there because they depend upon Peking, which is without influence or force. The fact is that the treaties can be kept continuous only through the use of force; either force by the Powers or force exercised by the Chinese Government. If there is no Central Government to make the treaties vital, then the Powers should do business with whatever Government there is in the land, And it is obvious that the only Governments which are real, in that they can support their mandates and agreements by force, are the de facto local Governments, it is wisdom and realism to work with those de facto Governments.
As regards the protection of life and property, Peking has ceased to protect foreign life and property for many years. When bandits capture foreigners and hold them for ransom, it is the local governor who sends an expedition or troops or who negotiates with the bandit chiefs for the foreigner's safety.—If }goods are seized, the local consular officials have to deal with. local Chinese officials. What good does it do for the Powers to file a protest with the W: chiaopu against an outrage to life and property in the—provines, when the Waichiaopu and the Peking Government have no method of communicating with provincial authorities who despise and denounce it? Of what! all would negotiations between the American Minister in Peking, for instance, and the Waichiaopu be on the subject of the American missionaries who are being molested in Wuchow, Kuangsi? What use would a' diplomatic note to Dr. W. W. Yen be, if the matter under discussion concerned the city of Harbin? How long are the foreigners going to allow. three or four plausible young men, educated abroad, who exercise no authority in the country, who have no force behind them, to frighten great nations into accepting them as a Government! when the actual governors of the: land refuse even to receive correspondence from these young men? In the situation in which China finds itself to-day, the Powers cannot afford to be misled by idealistic conceptions of what might be or what ought to be: this is a time for realities and for common sense.
The opponents of the Peking Government have always accused the foreigners of bolstering up Peking against the whole country. Although many elements have been at work to generate anti-foreign movement, it must never be forgotten that one of the arguments used against the foreigner has been that he has supported one side against the other in China's constant internal quarrel. The Powers should be strictly neutral in such a quarrel and neutrality means to support neither one party nor the other, to give aid to no one, but to demand protection of life and property and the continuity of written agreements until those agreements are changed by} mutual consent. Such neutrality implies that the Powers must withhold whatever prestige and support their recognition of any one side provides from every faction and every group until! China has been unified by popular consent and some form of government has! been recognized by the Chinese people through their effective Provincial governments. The opponents of Peking suggest that there can be no constitutional government and no permanent solution of. China's problems because a few men are able to.get hold of one city of the country, Peking, and through this single
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.