Feb. 23.
We have regretfully to say that we are in total disagreement with the resolution adopted. yesterday by the Associated British Chambers' of Commerce regarding the proposed 2} per cent. surtax. Nor do we think that aught but disapproval for it will be felt by the Chinese business community. To them it will merely appear that the Chambers' primary interest is to get a loan floated out of which the claims of some of their number may be met and that this essential object is not to be concealed by secondary proposals to. use the residue for disbandment of troops. Furthermore a very large part of China's floating indebtedness is represented by the Nishihara loans to the Anfu party in 1918. We do not say that this money ought not to be repaid. We do say that it is the most unpopular of all the millstones hanging about Peking's neck, a liability for which the country in no way considers itself responsible, and that the British Chambers' acquiescence in the notion of new loans to pay off the Nishihara claims is enough to condemn their proposals" in the eyes of all China, The resolution begins excellently. "The establishment in China of a Government able to exercise control of the Provinces and enforce its Mandates therein" is indeed ''an essential preliminary to all reforms.'' It is when we come to ''the necessary steps towards the establishment of an effective Government"' that the Chambers have gone so blindly astray. Have they seriously considered what ''disarmament under foreign supervision'' would mean? To be effective it means foreign officers in every big city of China; the device of giving the provinces so much money for disbandment and taking their account of how they spent it, was tried in 1913, and we know what came of that. Imagine the most distinguished general the West could furnish arriving at the tuchun's yamen, no further from Peking, let us say, than Kaifeng fu and announcing that he had come to disband the troops. The immense geographical size of China, to: say nothing of the language difficulty, makes the whole scheme fantastical. Consider also the malign forces that would be stirred up among those whose perquisites were menaced. Tt would be very easy for them to put such a construction on this machine of disarmament under foreign supervision as might lead to serious disturbances. For the Chinese naturally believe their own people in preference to foreigners. It would be ''sovereign rights'' with a vengeance.
And turning to the financial part of the Chambers' scheme, the mere reference to ''the Government', whose floating indebtedness must be met, begs the whole question. ~It assumes that there is in Peking a government which, with enough money, might be galvanized into life and action, linstead of, as is the true state of affairs, a row of marionettes hold-
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.