The Archive · 1930

PROVISIONAL, COURT PROTEST

Mr. Meinhardt Takes Exception to an Adjournment

fed ngninst the action of a Pro-important. protest. has been visional Court Judge in connection with [the Cauit recently brought against the Grand Theatre, The: protest is on the part of Mr. ©. D. Moinhardt, Beniot Consul's Deputy, and hus been called for because of the action of the Judge in question in adjourning the hearing of the case until next month, in which connection, it. will be noted, the point arises that by then the Provsional Court will have been transformed in the Shanghai: Special District Court in accordance with the terms the Provisional Court Reorganization Agreement, This means that no Deputies will then sit, and it is in this connection that Mr. Meinhardt has lodged his protest, which is In necordance with the duty imyesed on me by the Mixed Court Rentlition Aytecment, Tam reluctantly compelled" to protest against this decision to "adjourn the vase for further trial," ie, until next month, so that it could be tried without the p¥esente on the bench of 1 Senior Consul's Deputy. Since Deputies ure heiring other cases, he question naturally arises, why his particular case should be singled yut for adjournment solely to avoid he Rendition Agreement, pmgliute with the clear terms of Lest it should be thought that I vii over-zealous in seeking to protect he American company called the irand Theatre Corporation or its resident, who is the accused in his case, it should be stated that vas not sitting jointly as an Ameri-n Consul and that the corporation not a party to the action, My resenco on the bench was required inder Art 1, Section 8, of the Rendi-ion Agreement which yeads:—"In all criminal ease In which the accused Is in the employ of a fotelgner having extraterritorial

point 'a deputy to sit with the Wights, the Senior Consul may ap-Judge to watch the proceedings."

Now it was argued by the counsel or the complainant that no juristic etsons of foreign nationality, including corporations, had extraterrights, whetoas in the of fact such rights have not ut by all the Chinese Governments ing recognised in the court, power, since relations with yesterners were established, Counsel further contended that the grand Theatre Corporation was not purely American corporation since jock were held by Chinese and ritish as well as Americans. With nis contention T have. such ymputhy, as T realize that the Chiese shares and: interests in this company overshadow all others. m even ready to affirm that i¢ is not ne intention of either the Chinese foreign governments in ente ito treaties providing for extratertovinlity, that Chinese should be permitted to organize foreign cor-orations for operation in China they would be exempt from control of Chinese laws yurts, So it is not at all strange lat companies of this kind are not roistered with the American ansulate-General or riven protect-the American Government. evertholess in absence of any revile agreements dealing with the abject, there appears to be thority in law for dealing with a nrporation of this kind differently. om others in which the stock is entirely by nationals of the many in which they were incor-

The nationality of the corporation always that of the country which ranted its charter or articles of inporation. It follows, then, that Grand Theatre Corporation is an merican company, having been inporated in the state of Delaware, counsel for the plaintiff was con-stent in the aforesaid contentions would have brought charges rains the corporation as well a8 president. By not doing #0, he! mself recognized tht his arguent had no force. The precedents id decisions which he cited have no ring on the question of the contution of this court, inasmuch as circumstances or facts are tively different, and so they are 2f help to the court in ruling on question raised, Tt was further contended by. counsel that the Rendition Agreement was no longer in force because the National Government had issued late abolishing extratertitorlality as from January 1, 1930. Apparently counsel chose to overlook the accepted interpretation of the mandate, that it was an expression of certain principles to be gradually put into effect. The injunction therein calling pon foreigners to obey Chinese laws and ordinances was merely a re-statement of accepted principles guiding all right-thinking foreign residents enjoying extra territoriality rights, insofar as their obligations under the laws and ordinances of their own countries are permitted, By his postponement of the trial the learned judge no doubt was able to evade rendering a decision displeasing to the complainant and his followers, but there was no good reason why this issue should have been on the meri hand taken in conjunction with the conduct of the trial on March 13, when partiality towards the complainant was repeatedly shown, it is self-evident that the accused is not being-tried"on the charges made in the complaint, but is being made to suffer on account of his position in an American firm against which the complainant has made no attenipt to take action directly, well knowing that his charges are baseless. For the sole purpose of guarding against abuses of this nature the Rendition Agreement contained the provision quoted in. the second paragraph above. Neither has action'been taken against the officer of the corporation directly "responsible for the complainant's arrest after the latter} ied disturbance: in the theatre.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account