Before Judges Chung, Sung and in the civil appeal court of the provisional Court on March 26, the Grand 'Theatre appealed against a judgment which was given against them when J. W. Rotte brought a civil claim for $1,680 in the lower court, the sum representing several months' salary he had not received after his dismissal from the theatre.
When the case was heard in the lower court the defendant contended that plaintiff, who was the conductor of the orchestra, had refused to obey an order from the manager when told that he would bbe, required fora time to turn the handle of a gramophone which was installed in the theatre, when the "talkies" were used.
The plaintiff alleged that the defendant had committed a breach of contract in dismissing him before the expiration of the sagreement he had with the theatre.
He further alleged that the disnuissal was deliberate, and that the manager had been ready to get rid of him on the least provocation, he had no use for his orchestra, Dr."F. Wilhelm who" appeared for the plaintiff said that the defendant in filing the grounds for appeal brought up some points which were never contested in the Tower court, Counsel asked the court to dismiss the ease with costs.
The presiding judge, Mr. Wenfa Yiko Hu said thet in the agreement Yetween plaintiff and defendant, the plaintiff was required to change his Position and do other work without demur if so called upon, but had refused to operate a gramophone when asked to, Dr. Wilhelm said that if the plaintiff? had been asked to change his position and work in a manner which would not hurt his professional reputation he would gladly have done s0, but he was asked to something which would place him in an inferior capacity. He "gave as an example that if he asked policeman to sweep the courtroom, the officer would certainly resent the work as it was not within the scope of his duty.
After further hearing judgment was reserved.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.