The Archive · 1926

Alleged Misconduct

Defendants, in their reply, con tended that the plaintiff misconduct ed himself by refusing to pay his private debts and that he contracted Gebts with advertisers in the paper, some of whom consequently would not. pay for their advertisements, whilst others withdrew their's. They objected to him being associated with other papers, but he continued that course. He further improperly represented himself as editor Of the defendants' papers and being in charge of their advertise ments and circulation. They claimed that they were entitied to dismiss him without notice.

Mr. Kentwell, in opening the case, said that the issue seemed to be} very simple, although the defendants in their reply hed sct forth many matters that were irrelevant. and that fended to cloud the inst Gregson said that the plaintiff had subpoenaed a number of employees of the "Shanghai Mercury" who then were in Court. It was obviously very inconve for n concern carrying on the bus ness of newspaper publishers that they should not have in their office certain people who were competent conduct affairs and therefore he! asked that such witnesses should be dealt with as soon as possible and released.

The Judge agreed.

Mr. Kentwell asked for the ox-[clusion of all witnesses from Court Mr. Gregcon—That is at the di cretion of the Judge. There is one! witness who now is engaged in his business of reporting and I ask that be allowed to remain in Court.

Mr, Kentwell pressed his applica. tion, saying that it was important this witness also should be excloded. Mr, Palamountain, another reporter. way in Cart and could do the work, Me. Gregson—Mr. Palamountai {is not a verbatim reporter and Mr. Davis is the regular Court reporter! of the paper.

The Judge excluded all other esses, but allowed Mr. Davis to Temain, stating that there was no embarrassment.

'A Question of Capital Kentwell then called Mx. A.W.

jekey, who said that he was secretary of the defendant company and a proof-reader on the paper. He was asked what was the capital of the company, but, Mr. Gregson objected, saying that it had nothin. whatever to do with the case.

Mr. Kentwell—It may have something to do with the financial standing. 3 The Judge—That may come it when the case is finished.

Die. Kentwell—How mang shareholders are there?

Mr. Gregson—I object to that, too.

The Judge—What has that got to do with it?

Me. "Kentwell—We allege that oners is a Japanese interest." hai Mercury" and also was interest-Eventually he felt the call of ed in "Lloyd's Weekly" and the East and tried to get an appoint 'Shanghai Ladies' Journal.' ment. His father invested some Mr. Kentwell—I take it, with Mr. money in-a company and witness Davey's knowledge and consent?—came out for that company, selling T have not consulted him on the whiskey and watches and with one or two agencies, Everything weir take it that he knows of it?—well, but in May, 1024, his draft did Oh, yes. not come through and he ascertained Witness said that previously he that the company had gone ints had been temporarily employed on} Tiquidation. Replying to. an the "Mercury." He helped them out vertisement in the "North-China in Mr. Clark's time, occupying his Daily News" he was engaged by chair whilst he was away.

Mr, Davey as assistant on the Have you been sued in this Court? indoor staff of the "Mercury." The ~Yes. day after he joined Mr, Davey askd On a judgment summons?—Yor: for a leading article, which resulted and Tam paying, and you know in Mr. Davey asking him to writs The Judge—I don't see what thix the leaders every day and Me. has got to do with it.

Donaldson was dismissed. For a Mr. Kentwell—One of the reasons month witness shared duties with given is that because plaintiff was Tady and from July, 1924, until May sued he was dismissed, 80, 1925, the editor's office way The Judge—No: it is suggested shared by witness and Mr, Sherritt, that his creditors came to the "Moi a piece of brown paper being pasted cary" to geet their money. over "Editor" on the door. Witness Me. Gregson—And also that we wrote the leading article almost ould not Ret money for our adver every day, Mr, Sherriff only writing fisements. tone or two, On May 20 Sherriff and The compradore of the defendant) Davey had words about the control firm said that he had advanced of the Chinese staff and there wat money to the plaintiff on Mr, Davey "quite a shindy," as a result of instructions only. which Sherriff was told to clear out Shroffs Turned Away Davey then sent for witness and asked him to take over the paper Cross-examined—The most, he and thereafter he was solely re-thought, was $100, but it might have sponsible for everything that went been more. Many shroffs called, at to it, When he joined he receive the office for Mr. Haynes, who "al-$200 per month and this was me ways put them off." Witness identi-creased in states up to $100, th" fied compradore orders made out on. latter salary beginning, in Novembe him and signed by plaintiff for pay-1925. ment to Edward Ezra & Ca. These Witness did what he liked, the he had refused to pay. policy of the paper being entirely Mr. Kentwell—Are these anything, his own, Tt was completely changed to do with the case? because' "Mr. Donaldson was a The Judge—They are part of the Scottish Liberal and Tainan on! pleadings. You would be the first ind-out Conservative." Witness wa to object if Mr, Gregson did not} in full control of the reporters. rove his cas When witness joined the paper, Mr.

Witness identified other com.

Davey said he was himself editorpradore orders that he had refused in-chief and he was so styled in the to pay and said there were plenty: Hong List one year, but Mr. Davey of others, In some eases money had took it out the next'year. He acted been left to pay them, but when there fay managing director and was in was no money he would not pay. charge of the job printing departs Re-examined—Mr, Haynes always ment, but, had nothing to do with left some money to pay city and the editorial side and during wit-witness never was asked to pay when ness's time he only once wrote a there was no money. There were Toeal paragraph, Gande, Price and seven foreign employes on the "Mer-Ca, sent round a consignment of cury" and sometimes shroffs called beer and it went to Davey's house. for them. Shroffs called every day.

Davey wrote a paragraph, took it to Mr. Gregson—I don't think the the composing room and watched witness quite understood the ques-being set up. "It was all done sitetion. reptitiously. That was his only Mr, A. J. Richardson said that he contribution in 22 months unless by was an auctioneer, merchant, comte acknowledged any other beer chat mission agent "and anything." Te did not notice." was also a director of the "Shangha A Frank Op Mercury." Mr, W. J, Davey was managing director, but he could not Witners considered that quite recollect the name of the other was mentally and phy: director. He thought it was Takiro. capable of editing, a 'There had been a change recen'

"Look at the letters he wrote me! The engagement and dismissal of He can't write Englisht He also employees Was in the hands of Mr. was on rather affectionate terms Davey as managing director and he with Bacchus." had full powers. It was reported One day Mr, Davey turned a few to the board who were proper per-lines of a leader and witness was sons to keep in the firm and who very indignant and wrote, to. hint, not. considering it a piece of imperi Bir. Kentwell—T put it to you that fence and @ breach of the unwritten Mr. Davey runs the whole concern. lays, Mr, Davey apologised and ad.

Mr, Gregson—I object to that. mitted having been hot-tempered. Mr. Kentwell cannot cross-examine Witness only approached Davey ones hig own witness. on the question of a leading article.

The Judge upheld the objection.

They wore very short, of report Mr. Kentwell—And he manages and the "China Press" had no very well. porter in the British Court. hess used to we over to help out i's Life Story the "Mercury" were so, shorthanded, ving evidence, described "Day after day the China Press! himself as a journalist and said plagiarized ray copy." he said. was 28 that day. Prior to the war he did a good deal of writing for Laid a Trap the papers. He was invalided out "Ltaid traps for them and ome day of the Army in 1917 and went to the Tinvented a complete story to see Federated Malay. "States undo they would bite, and they: bit, "Ab

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account